So on wikipedia here it says the formula for electron degeneracy, which is dependent on a few constants and the mass of the proton and electron:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_d ... y_pressure
i'm also interested in neutron degeneracy pressure. however, this time i could not find anything at all. i did however, stumble upon this page which just gives a general pressure for degenerate fermion matter. http://quantummechanics.ucsd.edu/ph130a ... de204.html
my question is, why is electron degeneracy pressure dependent on the mass of the proton and electron while the fermion degeneracy pressure is only dependent on a single mass. is one or both of the equations incorrect? can neutron degeneracy pressure be calculated with the second equation?
one possible cause could be that electrons and protons have opposite charges, so they attract, unlike neutrons. is this the case?
electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
Moderators: gmalivuk, Moderators General, Prelates

 Posts: 21
 Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2012 6:20 pm UTC
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
It's because if there are electrons in your white dwarf, there are also protons to keep the total charge neutral. So both the electron mass and the proton mass will matter. In neutron star matter, the protons and electrons have 'fused' to neutrons so they are the only relevant particle.
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
that seems to make sense. thanks!
about the 'fusing' of protons and electrons, if i want to calculate the neutron degeneracy pressure of a single helium4 atom, i should use 4 as the number of neutrons?.
about the 'fusing' of protons and electrons, if i want to calculate the neutron degeneracy pressure of a single helium4 atom, i should use 4 as the number of neutrons?.
 thoughtfully
 Posts: 2253
 Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2007 12:25 am UTC
 Location: Minneapolis, MN
 Contact:
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
>) wrote:that seems to make sense. thanks!
about the 'fusing' of protons and electrons, if i want to calculate the neutron degeneracy pressure of a single helium4 atom, i should use 4 as the number of neutrons?.
Since they're bosons, I'm not sure there's any degeneracy pressure. But I'm more wiseguy than smartypants on this subject matter.
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
according to this wikipedia chart they fall under baryons/hardons. however, you're still right that they're not fermions: http://i.snag.gy/xybGC.jpg
they should have degeneracy pressure : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degenerate ... degeneracy
"Neutron degeneracy is analogous to electron degeneracy and is demonstrated in neutron stars, which are primarily supported by the pressure from a degenerate neutron gas.[7]"
i'm quite interested in finding an equation that can describe neutron degeneracy pressure. does anyone have any ideas?
edit: ahha! the term 'neutron gas' did it. i found this via google: http://es.ucsc.edu/~glatz/astr_112/lectures/notes18.pdf which gives a pressure formula similar to that of fermions.
they should have degeneracy pressure : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degenerate ... degeneracy
"Neutron degeneracy is analogous to electron degeneracy and is demonstrated in neutron stars, which are primarily supported by the pressure from a degenerate neutron gas.[7]"
i'm quite interested in finding an equation that can describe neutron degeneracy pressure. does anyone have any ideas?
edit: ahha! the term 'neutron gas' did it. i found this via google: http://es.ucsc.edu/~glatz/astr_112/lectures/notes18.pdf which gives a pressure formula similar to that of fermions.
 gmalivuk
 GNU Terry Pratchett
 Posts: 26576
 Joined: Wed Feb 28, 2007 6:02 pm UTC
 Location: Here and There
 Contact:
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
Given that the size limit on neutron stars has been calculated as between 1.5 and 3.0 solar masses, I suspect the formula for neutron degeneracy pressure is not known nearly as precisely as that for electrons, or else they'd be able to calculate a tighter limit.

 Posts: 239
 Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2009 9:58 am UTC
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
Yeah, we don't know the nuclear matter equation of state yet. It's one of the big unknowns in neutron star physics, and it almost certainly does not have an analytic form. People have been doing/trying to do numerical simulations of it for 3040 years now, but still haven't had definitive success.
You missed thoughtfully's point. He4 nuclei are bosons, because they are spin 0. Bosons are particles with integer spin, fermions have halfinteger spin. The Wiki page lists fundamental bosons and fermions, not composite ones.
The neutron degeneracy pressure formula you found has exactly the same form as the one for electrons, because they are both fermions. When deriving the degeneracy pressure, you start by dealing with identical fermions of some mass, charge, etc. Then you can plug and play for gases composed of different particles. This is exactly what the second link you posted showed. Because bosons do not follow the Pauli Exclusion Principle, they do not have degeneracy pressure.
However, as those lecture notes hint at, this is not the whole story when it comes to neutrons. It turns out that the equation given is a nonrelativistic, lowdensity approximation to the real thing. At neutron star densities, you must take relativity and the nuclear forces between neutrons into account. This is why we have known the general properties of white dwarf interiors for a long time, but still know next to nothing about the deep interiors of neutron stars.
>) wrote:according to this wikipedia chart they fall under baryons/hardons. however, you're still right that they're not fermions: http://i.snag.gy/xybGC.jpg
You missed thoughtfully's point. He4 nuclei are bosons, because they are spin 0. Bosons are particles with integer spin, fermions have halfinteger spin. The Wiki page lists fundamental bosons and fermions, not composite ones.
The neutron degeneracy pressure formula you found has exactly the same form as the one for electrons, because they are both fermions. When deriving the degeneracy pressure, you start by dealing with identical fermions of some mass, charge, etc. Then you can plug and play for gases composed of different particles. This is exactly what the second link you posted showed. Because bosons do not follow the Pauli Exclusion Principle, they do not have degeneracy pressure.
However, as those lecture notes hint at, this is not the whole story when it comes to neutrons. It turns out that the equation given is a nonrelativistic, lowdensity approximation to the real thing. At neutron star densities, you must take relativity and the nuclear forces between neutrons into account. This is why we have known the general properties of white dwarf interiors for a long time, but still know next to nothing about the deep interiors of neutron stars.
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
i see what you mean by the composite and fundamental bosons/fermions now.
when a he4 atom is subjected to pressures where neutron degeneracy pressure is significant, the protons and electrons have broken down so that they're all fermions with degeneracy pressure, correct?
So, when computing the neutron degeneracy pressure of a mol of helium4 per nm^3, should i use 4 mols of neutrons per nm^3 since the protons and electrons have 'merged'?
when a he4 atom is subjected to pressures where neutron degeneracy pressure is significant, the protons and electrons have broken down so that they're all fermions with degeneracy pressure, correct?
So, when computing the neutron degeneracy pressure of a mol of helium4 per nm^3, should i use 4 mols of neutrons per nm^3 since the protons and electrons have 'merged'?
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
>) wrote:when a he4 atom is subjected to pressures where neutron degeneracy pressure is significant, the protons and electrons have broken down so that they're all fermions with degeneracy pressure, correct?
According to the Standard Model electrons don't break down since they're fundamental particles. (OTOH, there are some speculations that they aren't truly fundamental).
The relevant equation is:
proton + electron + energy → neutron + neutrino
This is just a rearrangement of the equation for the decay of a free neutron via the weak nuclear force, aka the beta decay equation:
neutron → proton + electron + antineutrino + energy
where the released energy is generally in the form of kinetic energy of the resulting particles; from conservation of momentum it can easily be shown that most of the KE goes into the electron & antineutrino.
Spoiler:
>) wrote:So, when computing the neutron degeneracy pressure of a mol of helium4 per nm^3, should i use 4 mols of neutrons per nm^3 since the protons and electrons have 'merged'?
Well, as I (hopefully) explained above, the protons and electrons haven't actually merged, per se, but yes, each ^{4}He atom gets converted into 4 neutrons (and 2 neutrinos).
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
that's a fascinating indepth explanation. thank you!
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
The hydrostatic equation that describes neutrondegenerate stuff is the Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff equation, which is analogous to the hydrostatic equation derived by Chandrasekhar for electrondegenerate matter. This gives rise to the Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff limit to the maximum mass of a neutron star. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tolman%E2% ... f_equation
The TOV limit for the maximum mass of a neutron star has a fair bit of uncertainty in it, compared to the Chandrasekhar limit for the limiting mass of a white dwarf, because an accurate equation of state for neutron degenerate matter doesn't exist.
The TOV limit for the maximum mass of a neutron star has a fair bit of uncertainty in it, compared to the Chandrasekhar limit for the limiting mass of a white dwarf, because an accurate equation of state for neutron degenerate matter doesn't exist.
...suffer from the computer disease that anybody who works with computers now knows about. It's a very serious disease and it interferes completely with the work. The trouble with computers is you play with them. They are so wonderful.  Richard Feynman
Re: electron degeneracy, neutron degeneracy, and pressure?
Minerva wrote:The hydrostatic equation that describes neutrondegenerate stuff is the Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff equation, which is analogous to the hydrostatic equation derived by Chandrasekhar for electrondegenerate matter. This gives rise to the Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff limit to the maximum mass of a neutron star. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tolman%E2% ... f_equation
The TOV limit for the maximum mass of a neutron star has a fair bit of uncertainty in it, compared to the Chandrasekhar limit for the limiting mass of a white dwarf, because an accurate equation of state for neutron degenerate matter doesn't exist.
If this was any other forum, I would attribute this to crazy sciency words just being strung together for Sci Fi purposes. Actual science is crazy.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests