I really enjoyed this, but felt there were a few story arcs that were completely superfluous. Talia had no real reason to be included in the storyline other than to be yet another counterpoint to Bruce, a 'le twist!' point later on, and a reminder that Bruce can never, ever, enjoy anything in life.
Now, I know I've expressed some anti-Occupy movement sentiment around here. This film made me uncomfortable at times with how absurdly heavy handed it was taking the 'Occupy movement gone too far' rhetoric. My friend claimed that it was a sort of Rorschach test on the viewer, that it was intentionally ambiguous as to whether or not Bane or Batman was the true liberator in such circumstance, but man, on a first pass, I was wincing, feeling like my Republican relatives had written this part of the script.
Ultimately, it was pretty good, I felt, with Alfred stealing the show in terms of emotional speeches, but the story arc of these films is just too tired at this point; someone comes in who haves everything planned, and wins the day. Batman steps up to the plate, gets his ass beat, and goes into hiding. Gotham suffers, hard, and then Batman comes and rescues everyone, and then some cut scenes reveal cool stuff about the story, like le gasp, things aren't what we thought they were! Sigh.
Oh, also; the action was very poorly done. CQC was weak and uninspired, and Batman's gadgets were hardly used. At one point, he even pulls out some neato looking raygun, and a cop apologetically shoots it; I felt this was some kind of shoddy foreshadowing, a statement that 'In this film, Batman will have no cool gadgets or trickses up his sleeve, because, well, for no reason at all'
Can someone explain to me why the Scarecrow guy (Killian Murphy?) was the arbiter in the mock court? That seemed WHOLLY random.