Logic Puzzles Rules - Update 2013

[TheTankengine]

Of course, standard fora etiquette applies. Beyond that -

1. We have a spoiler policy to allow newcomers to solve old puzzles.
2. We ask that once you post a puzzle don't remove it.
3. When you post a puzzle, alert people if there is no known answer, and provide an answer after people have given it a decent go.
4. Trick questions are not puzzles and will be moderated appropriately.

[Wildcard]

I have a question. If you want to repost and/or further discuss a puzzle which was posted a long time ago, is it preferable to:

1. Necro post and revive the old, original thread for the puzzle?
2. Just start a new thread even though the puzzle was posted before?

Or, a compromise:
3. Start a new thread but include a link to the old thread?

Does it make a difference if the aspect of the original puzzle you want to discuss is actually a variation which was proposed in the replies to that original puzzle?

(I rather expect my post to be moved from this thread to keep it cleared out, but I'm hoping I can first get an answer, and this seems like the place to ask.)

[jestingrabbit]

If its a variation, post a new puzzle. If its just some aspect of the old, then necro.

[Wildcard]

Okay, thanks!