I've agreed that it isn't a good idea to mass claim (town roles, mind - I don't think there is any risk to claiming previously owned scum roles) until we have confirmation that the spinning will continue. Because the room spin was the entire motivation for claiming.Minestrone wrote:This may not be a normal game but as you yourself have even admitted by now it's still not a good idea to massclaim. So I don't see what your point is?
Minestrone's second post wrote:That's not an accurate representation of what I said. I never said that you never admitted to being wrong, only that you stuck with the idea for a couple posts until it was clear everyone was against you, which you did.
??? In your first post, you condemn me for supporting my own suggestion, and in your second post you condemn me for agreeing that my suggestion has weaknesses. And again, you've somehow missed that I still think it is a worthy idea if the roomspin continues. I literally have not changed my stance, and you're saying I'm defending it too much and not enough.Minestrone's first post wrote:I don't like the way Van is talking about mass claiming on the assumption that roles will keep changing without recognizing that a) the room has stopped spinning and b) there's no way the roles can just keep changing if this game is going to work at all. ( ... ) Other than Van's suggestion (and more scummily, their continuing to push it for a couple posts instead of dropping it) I haven't noticed anything standing out as scummy in today's discussion.
My vote stays.