That is correct.
bessie wrote:I’ve heard that the only stupid question is the one not asked.
bessie wrote:Mod, what was the phase of the moon on N3?
Well OK, I’m on my own. Stream of consciousness, here’s a summary of everyone’s claims and what I’m thinking right now.
Vytron, Rumplestiltskin, Mafia, various powers (one per night), lynched D1. This must have been a very powerful role. More on this later.
Madge, Magic Mirror, Independent Regina aligned (assumed scum), Name Cop, lynched D2. Claimed she investigated SDK N1 and got a result of Granny.
mpolo, Emma, Town, Cop/Lie Detector, killed N2. Did not make any claims, but there are some breadcrumbs that he investigated Ben N1 and got a result of town.
Djehutynakht/SPACKlick, Dr. Frankenstein, Town, Doctor/Resurrection, lynched D3. I can’t find any breadcrumbs as to who SPACKlick targeted on N1, and DJ didn’t post any actual content on D3 so if he used his power there are no clues.
SDK, Granny, Town, Tracker/Race Cop, killed N3. I think there is some indication SDK targeted Madge on N1. He was ready to believe her town claim but something she said led him to believe she lied, and changed his mind and voted for her. Also, SDK was sure he was redirected on N1.
bessie’s WAG (wild ass guess): SDK was redirected, but it was by Madge. She was a Mirror. My guess is that SDK tracked her N1 and got a result of tracking her to her own house and a result of werewolf, and he believed she was Red. Reminder: SPACKlick pointed out a strange lie detector claim by Madge that she didn’t have control over a kill, and Lawrencelot thought Madge might be Red too. Madge claimed she targeted SDK. It was after her claim that SDK changed his mind on Madge and said she lied, I think because his result didn’t match her claim. That’s when he claimed to have been redirected.
I haven’t figured out who SDK tracked on N2, or if it’s important.
bessie, claimed Red Riding Hood, Town, Vigilante, unblockable and unnightkillable N3. Claimed to target dimochka on N3.
Lawrencelot, claimed Prince Charming, Town, Mason/Double Voter/One-shot NK immunity (after Emma’s death). A quick read of the thread found this. I’ll just leave it here for now.
Lawrencelot wrote:Right, I forgot I have a double vote today.
I wasnt told who it came from but I have a pretty good idea about that, which I wont reveal.
Lawrencelot wrote: I am a mason too obviously, and I get a 1-shot nightkill immunity and a double vote when Emma dies.
Dr Ug/JudeMorrigan, claimed Snow White, Town, Mason/Unnightkillable (if Red is alive).
BenM16, claimed Henry, Town, Town Power Backup/Unkillable by Regina (assumed from flavor). Inherited mpolo’s Cop (did you also inherit the lie detector?). Claimed he investigated dimochka N3 and got a result of Town (I missed this earlier). Ben, please answer this.
BenM16 wrote:3. Dr Ug is a really really good maf. (Unlikely)
Why is this unlikely? I think this a good possibility.
dimochka, claimed Belle, Town, Roleblocker. Claimed to block Dr Ug N1 and N2. Claimed to block Lawrencelot N3.
Some comments from dimochka’s last post.
dimochka wrote:Bessie - You keep mentioning the part about people being shown as mafia or non-human only when they use their actions. But I claimed that I used an action well before you said that today, and before Ben claimed to have visited me and seen me as town. Sounds somewhat inconsistent to me.
My non-human/non-town theory is not new. I have been saying this for a while. If you want some quotes I can dig them up but really just search my posts and you should come up with many starting very near the beginning of D2. And if you are scum and used a power and investigated as town, then I am wrong, which is a possibility, and I don’t think anyone else ever agreed with me on this either. Or if I’m right then it’s just more evidence that you are town.
dimochka wrote:Lawrencelot - were you roleblocked last night? Because if you were then I used an action, and then based on Bessie's rules I should be shown as mafia / non-human. Or am I now a full godfather?
If dimochka is scum, then he had to use an action, because SDK is dead. Either he killed SDK, or he somehow redirected my kill to SDK. Maybe.
Here’s a question: why is SDK dead? Did scum kill him? Did bessie kill him? And in a related question, what’s the deal with bessie’s unblockable kill? Another WAG from bessie: SDK somehow interfered with my kill. He was Granny, maybe he was trying to give me his cloak or something and I killed him. Or I got the cloak so I didn’t change into a werewolf.
Some general observations.
Town appears to be much overpowered. We had a doctor that can resurrect the dead and four varying bulletproof claims: Lawrencelot (one shot), Snow White (unNKable when Red is alive), bessie (unNKable N3), and Ben (unNKable by Regina).
The scum faction(s) must be powerful to balance all the town kill immunity. Vytron must have had a scum partner, the flavor said he was Mafia. We know Regina is in the game.
Possible scum distribution that might work:
Mafia is Rumplestiltskin and Regina, both very powerful. Magic Mirror becomes full Mafia if she finds Regina, and possibly gains another power.
Rumplestiltskin is Mafia with someone else. Regina is Independent, Magic Mirror is Independent and gains communication with Regina if they locate each other, and they become a second scum team. Regina has a kill (implied by flavor in Henry’s role).
That's all I have for now. I will probably think of something else right after I post this.