Gopher of Pern wrote:If I were scum, you would still have to find the other scum. Madge is a possibility, sure. But even so, I could have been setting her up.
Madge claims to have seen you targeting her. If you flip as simple Goon or GF or Ninja or anything that doesn't have a targeting ability then she was lying and is scum. Unfortunately I think you're Rolecop and that won't help us in the end.
Gopher of Pern wrote:A NL will provide more information.
If you can convince Madge to follow my plan then maybe. Good luck with that. My plans are always good for Town even if I'm scum, as acknowledged e.g. here
Gopher of Pern wrote:Thing is, your downsides are not downsides, because dimochka is scum.
You should be fully aware that this argument doesn't work.
Gopher of Pern wrote:Sabrar, if you are indeed town: Why do you think I'm scum? Can you provide anything aside from an unbelievable claim (which, despite the wine, I'll point out that I would not have made up myself as a falseclaim, especially after my analysis on what you think the setup was originally.)?
- Your claim is not consistent with previous content, dimochka's claim is.
- Your 'misdirection' is very low-key and I doubt it would make scum specifically think that you're not Cop.
- You have way too much wine.
- Your play is inconsistent with previous town!GoP as in by now you would be attacking me full-out for being scum and not trying to convince me that you're town.
These are off the top of my head, without reading back the thread.