post 1: joke unvotes, calls out jester
post 2: clarification of post 1
post 3: setup spec
post 4: views LaserGuy analysing joke votes as scum plausibility arguments. reads on bessie, plytho, and Sabrar all seem to be townie based on standard behavior
post 5: response to point in post 4 downplaying the against analysis part.
post 6: defending reads of bessie and Sabrar
post 7: brings up meta from other mafia sites
post 8: questions my reads list for having too many neutral reads, defense of Znirk's lurkiness
post 9: circling back to his part in the joke phase discussion, Laserguy slightly townie
post 10: suspicious of Znirk for being unoriginal in his reads with a conclusion of scummy feeling. commenting on PW's apple remark
post 11: looking for scum!Sabrar meta, concludes with no suspicion of him yet. question for bessie
I feel like most players as town would tend to be more stubborn and stick to their guns, while mafia will be more willing to appear open minded. So for me I feel like showing a willingness to reconsider would be more scum indicative.
In one way I agree because scum would be happy with any target besides their own they would have leeway to build any sort of "case" they wanted. OTOH, I would think town's lack of knowledge (especially D1) would make for less definitive opinions than heury thinks. As I've said before, certainty is for scum.
post 13&14: commenting on PW's second apple related remark.
post 15: questions plytho on his meta and flicky on his vote for me.
post 16: town to scum list with plytho at bottom. votes plytho with the notice of hammer minus one.
this post came almost immedately after I mentioned him going dark. Coincidence? I think SO.