Evil George Washington wrote:Since he should be targetting people that seem townie like me/sabrar/maven (who is dead). He wouldn't protect Boom since he scumread him. Frozen didn't seem townie at all. Ryu could have either withheld while his scum buddy confirms for him or he could have sent a kill instead of the supposed 'protection'. There is still the balance issue, and there is still the Boom VS Ryu issue.
This line of thinking was what I was getting at before. If you're assuming Red and Frozen are buddies, Frozen should be the lynch. If they're town, lynching Frozen saves the doctor. If they're scum we expose their lies.
That's why I asked
plytho wrote:Do you think Red would have sent a protection message to his buddy N1 instead of a townie?
Actually sending a note to a buddy sounds like strange strategy for scum N1. If we believe that note wasn't sent we have an easy way to prove it.