BoomFrog wrote:The kill choices have been very odd all game which makes me hesitant to read into them too deeply.
How can you say this when you use it to implicate Ryu here
? Also where does your read on Ryu liking riskier plays come from?
BoomFrog wrote:Sabrar is still scum lean but less confident with recent events. Still second or third scummiest though by PoE.
How does your PoE work?
I agree, analysing kill targets is fraught with assumptions. I'm just trying to think through any clues we have. I evaluate Red as a risk taker due to his cavalier style. He's less engaged with the game, which means he takes the game less seriously then others here do. (This is not a criticism, just an observation). EGW'S anecdote that Red drunk posts sometimes also informed this assessment. Anyway, I didn't say he likes risky play, I'm just saying he has the most potential for then others here.
My PoE is probably outdated, you are right. I need to reevaluate.
Red (would have protected Bessie)
Probably plytho, but he may have bussed Moody
Madge (Bessie was still seriously pushing her)
Me (wine, but whatever. I beat the drum for the Moody lynch and Bessie was gunning for me)
mpolo (too big a target for killers)
Red (wouldn't have killed his protectee)
Probably LaserGuy (judgment is too risky for an SK power)
Madge (can't be SK, if we get one killer and all NKs stop then maybe forced her to tree stump and let her get lynched by the last townie 1 vs 1. Unless Sabrar is a killer) (also half-jester SK is crazy)
That leaves LaserGuy and a distant plytho for last Mafia. And one or two of (Sabrar, Me, plytho, EGW, mpolo) as killers.
Killer bus driver is weird, but so is everything this game.
Bullet proof killer + one shot untargetable is a weird combination, so I doubt EGW is a lone SK.
Plytho and Sabrar fit with SK style abilities.
I'm leaning Laser as last Mafia and Sabrar or mpolo as SK. plytho was way too happy that Bessie was Mafia.
I'm going to sleep on it before voting though.
"Everything I need to know about parenting I learned from cooking. Don't be afraid to experiment, and eat your mistakes." - Cronos