moody7277 wrote: Discussion seems to have stalled out. Despite lemma 3's shakiness and his lemma 0 (more of an axiom really), I am on board with Sabrar's plan enough to go with lynching flicky, was mostly waiting to see if any further support for lynching Madge would develop and for us to reach this point debate-wise.
Why are you so quick to accept Sabrar=town as an axiom? And yeah, it’s kinda hard to play with Madge if she won’t play back.
Madge, how about some reads? Or at least a town-scum list?
jimbobmacdoodle wrote: The redirection claim makes everybody doubt their night results, which is clearly beneficial to scum, so it makes sense for scum!moody to claim this as much as town!moody.
moody posted and soft-confirmed he used his power almost at the start of D2, before everyone claimed. If moody is scum, where is the beneficial-to-scum confusion you’re talking about? People who posted before moody: Sabrar, jimbob.
jimbobmacdoodle wrote:@bessie - you said in your Lemma 2 analysis that you believe Sabrar could be buddies with Madge. What about moody?
Madge/moody? Why would they clear you? They could have killed you and cleared Madge (moody uses redirect, Madge was probably less likely than some others to be watched or doctored, but could have been jailed).
Some brief updated readsflicky1991/Suzaku
My read of Suzaku was scum, possibly with Madge. I’m trying to allow in my read flicky’s RL time constraints, and replacing before he expected, but I still don’t see anything in his content to dissuade me from my scum read of Suzaku. Leaning scum. jimbobmacdoodle
Analysis of jimbob+moody was that jimbob was scum with moody or town. I’ve agreed with much of his content in this game, and I would probably have him leading town even without moody’s redirect claim.Liri
My previous conclusion was that suspicious tells could be attributed to newbieness. I will reread him again and sleep on it, and possibly update this in the morning, but I’m willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for today because I have scummier reads.Madge
Has she even expressed a strong opinion on anyone except herself in this entire game? Everything has a qualifier, even her votes. Voted wam for self defense. Voted Liri to apply pressure. FoS’d Sabrar for not scumhunting himself? Why not analyze his post yourself, Madge? Leaning scum. moody7277
As already noted, I feel better about him (see previous moody+jimbob analysis). Currently leaning town.Sabrar
Same read as previously, probably not-mafia, if he was mafia my choice as his partner would be flicky or Madge. Still possible indie.