Vicarin wrote:@LaserGuy: helps make sure we don't waste investigative results getting blocked and possibly sending the Sash flying around all the people in the game. Main issue I see is scum knowing where it is helps them take it if they want it, but then if we agree publicly that targeting the Sash-claimer is a bad idea, anyone who ends up with the Sash in the meantime without the first person dying looks really, really scummy.
This is an excellent idea. Why didn't you state this until you were prodded for it?
To cut in and answer Jim's question: We'd coordinate targeting to retrieve the Sash from possible suspects. We'd essentially be using all targeting as pseudo-copping. (ninjad by vic but leaving here)Mark Related
Vicarin wrote:The more unfortunate thing is that by saying your logic, I'm pretty sure you've confirmed that you're not a VT that can't target, because otherwise you wouldn't be worried. Unless this is the greatest fake town-slip ever.
Why post this? It just helps scum.Vote: Vicarin
Not really. It's pretty obvious that you're a PR.
Mark_Cangila wrote:No, Zenii, I am against moving the sash on purpose because ut creates uncertainty and conflict
It does the exact opposite. Stop trying to sell me poo.
Openness = Less uncertainty, More Control
It's also interesting to me that you were aware of Night chat only. I had overlooked it.Moody Related
Zenii wrote:Why are you not voting Laser then?
Because while I am familiar enough with the trope to recognize it, I'm not confident enough in my ability to glean the same results the wielder would.
Man I love your poetic whit. Anyway, my concern with this is that you said the exact same thing in Crossover when I SDK'd your partner Heury. Even if you're not confident, surely it's a better start than mpolo? What do you think about the point I made about Laser's town reading?Jim Related
jimbobmacdoodle wrote:Why is mpolo, myself and any others who hadn't posted at that time a 9?
This is a weird question to ask, seeing as you've already stated this:
jimbobmacdoodle wrote:I think 8-2 is viable
So I'm pretty sure you can work it out.
@Zenii, why is plytho a 5 unlike every other townie player?
Also instinct. Just seems like he hasn't been scum in a while. I have high doubts about it though. I always have doubts about plytho.
@everybody else, why haven't you queried him on this already??
Vicarin wrote:I'd recommend reading page 2 of Stellaris, he's done it before.
He's fully aware, as he kept up with the gist of Stellaris
. So Jim it's pretty peculiar to me that you asked this.Laser Related
LaserGuy wrote:I think the questions he asked in pregame are strongly towntelling and I think him attempting a fake townslip is outside of his scum range at this point.
Vic is entirely capable of asking those questions as scum. Why are you assuming he has the theory of mind of a duck?
Your case is mostly NAI stuff that is standard Vicarin
So what is it: NAI or "Strongly towntelling"? You recognize that Vic is just Vic, yet you're town reading him? You're not actually scumhunting. I think you're likely just using your knowledge of whose town to make up reads. Also, if Vic is town for being Vic, why haven't you town read me for my being Zen?Zen Related
jimbobmacdoodle wrote:@Zenii, what do you think about Vicarin's mod questions in this post? Happy to hear from others too, but only after Zenii has answered.
My initial evaluation was that it was scummy because it was unnecessary given the questions I had just asked. That made me think that Vic was probably just asking questions to mimic his town meta. His reasoning is fair though so I'm classifying it as null.