Okay, officially dead now. Before I start reading back through, I want to say three things:
1) I'm growing increasingly suspicious that joshz/BoomFrog was potentially a vig (or even the SK, though that's less likely by far), and roband actually was innocent. In which case, GG town.
2) Well, you lynched me. Congratulations. Was it worth it? I guess we'll see D5. :>
3) Enjoy the day-start flavor. ^_^
EDIT AFTER READING: Nope, was right about roband. I suppose "deadly neurotoxin on tie" is a valid way of resolving the situation :>
And Adacore - I don't think your second scenario there works. If a townie OR sk was lynched today, it'd go to 2 scum/2 non-scum, which would cause an immediate scum win (I think? If the deadly neurotoxin doesn't affect roband, then a town lynch would go to 0-1-2, then 0-1-1 that night, leading to SK win because we can't kill him of...maybe? IDK.
And Ibarra - fair enough, you had a strategy, though I'm not sure you're going to be able to convince people you're not scum. Frankly, I think the best (and most hilarious) course of action might be for everyone to claim their true roles and let town explicitly kingmaker...now it's just a question of whether EH realizes that *not roleblocking at all* has much more fascinating consequences...
Though really, for the "don't roleblock at all" to work, the best course of action would have been to put that out there, say "okay, not gonna roleblock" to lure SK into hitting scum (while scum hits town because they have to), then roleblock scum so the SK hands them the game. *THAT* was the only real viable town win strat - but it required a lot of wine, which wasn't properly placed before day end.
Furthermore, I'm still amused about last night. EH's logic failed it, but wound up coincidentally correct...aw man, does that mean if we'd targeted joshz/EH last night, we would have won right then when roband hit e_e?
Or did roband just no-kill last night?
FURTHER EDIT: If I'd been thinking about it, I would have considered roband's most likely target - I assumed he'd want to hit scum, and thus that it didn't matter which townie we chose if he wasn't roleblocked, but I didn't actually do out the math.
Ah, how different this game would have been if I'd woken up 5 minutes later that day...since it sounds like I could have convinced EH to lynch joshz. Instead, I outed myself, cleared joshz's name, and in the process implicated Ibarra by process of elimination, all in one swell foop, with that joshz vote-swap. If I'd just left it where it was, we'd prob. be winning right now.
Oh well, that's early-morning snap decision-making for you