Because I have knowledge of their conversation last night. And there were only three of them. A Black beast, a bunny rabbit, and an Old man were talking to each other. As we've already killed the Black beast and bunny rabbit, that just leaves the Old man. Besides, if I were a Cult Member, then why did I daykill AS?michaelandjimi wrote:1) Bulvox:What makes you sure that he is the final member? It may be possible that there are more. While I still reckon we should vote for Brooklynxman, I think we should be wary of Bulvox's alignment, for he very well could be a cult member throwing his buddies under the bus for the purposes of sneakiness.Bulvox wrote:Brooklynxman is the final one of the Keepers of Aaaaaaaaaaaagh!
Monty Python Mafia!: Town victory! French Military Defeats
Moderators: jestingrabbit, Moderators General, Prelates
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Night 1 - Only a flesh wound!

See Ya Space Cowboy...
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
EBWOP: I have the sneaking suspicion that I shan't live through the night...

See Ya Space Cowboy...
- Sir_Elderberry
- Posts: 4206
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2007 6:50 pm UTC
- Location: Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Ah. Go ahead, but it wasn't a roleclaim. At that point, we were trying to guess which movie roles corresponded to which Mafia ones. I said the French because they'd been mentioned, but as they're not the ones who actually beat Arthur, I didn't think it was so sure. Innocent speculation, but go ahead.
http://www.geekyhumanist.blogspot.com -- Science and the Concerned Voter
Well. You heard him.
Belial wrote:You are the coolest guy that ever cooled.
I reiterate. Coolest. Guy.
Well. You heard him.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
...holy cow! (pun totally intended).
Mostly because of this:
Followed by brooks subsequent roleclaim. I didn't think that was likely to be the sort of information that she would share if she was linked to brook, either. I guess it could have been flavour based on the movie though.
Anyway, une makes perfect sense.
Vote: Brooklynxman
MaJ wrote:2) Cycoden:Why is this?cycoden wrote:Also, it seems mollusk is either a good guesser, or is a seer of some sort.
Mostly because of this:
mollusk wrote:And if I may offer a humble suggestion,
Don't say "I don't know" if asked a question.
Followed by brooks subsequent roleclaim. I didn't think that was likely to be the sort of information that she would share if she was linked to brook, either. I guess it could have been flavour based on the movie though.
Anyway, une makes perfect sense.
Vote: Brooklynxman
VectorZero wrote:SEXUAL INTERCOURSE DISGUSTS ME!
Spoiler:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
*leaps on the passing bandwagon*
Vote: Brooklynxman
Vote: Brooklynxman
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
you...uh...you should probably bold your vote Rakysh.

See Ya Space Cowboy...
- michaelandjimi
- Isn't Even Playing
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2008 8:21 am UTC
- Location: Citizen of the World
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Though the evidence that the Dark Lord has returned Brooklynxman is cult is fairly incontrovertible, I feel that he should still have his say. By my count there are 19 players left, which means 10 to lynch. So can we wait for him before we lynch?
Whelan wrote:Relax, have a good time, and hope for the bees
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
It seems fairly obvious that brooklynxman is cult. However I am willing to withhold my vote for now to let him get a word in, as MaJ suggests.
yeah yeah yeah
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Ahem, it appears I missed the wagon >.<
Vote: Brooklynxman
Vote: Brooklynxman
- b.i.o
- Green is the loneliest number
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:38 pm UTC
- Location: Hong Kong
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Makes sense to me. Good catch une.
So at this point I'm guessing Bulvox is Tim the Enchanter. Seems the character most likely to be able to spy on the Aaaaaaargh-ers, and also perfectly capable of killing people. Probably town, if not, independent.
MaJ: I like that plan. Especially because he can ask someone a question before they die, and we may be able to convince him to ask something useful. Of course, he'll probably come up with something just to spite us.
So at this point I'm guessing Bulvox is Tim the Enchanter. Seems the character most likely to be able to spy on the Aaaaaaargh-ers, and also perfectly capable of killing people. Probably town, if not, independent.
MaJ: I like that plan. Especially because he can ask someone a question before they die, and we may be able to convince him to ask something useful. Of course, he'll probably come up with something just to spite us.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
You know b.i.o., if you suspect someone of being a major pro-town power role, it's usually best to not reveal your suspicions. You know, on the off chance that no one else has figured it out.

See Ya Space Cowboy...
- b.i.o
- Green is the loneliest number
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:38 pm UTC
- Location: Hong Kong
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I like to operate under the assumption that the people I'm playing against are just as intelligent as I am. And it's not as though I'm making some huge logical leap here. You yourself stated you thought you'd be dead by tomorrow anyway. Given the current circumstances, I think that that's pretty likely.
- michaelandjimi
- Isn't Even Playing
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2008 8:21 am UTC
- Location: Citizen of the World
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I don't think it was scummy of b.i.o., just silly. If he was scum he could just have told his buddies in the night, as it was fairly obvious that b.i.o. would survive until then.
Whelan wrote:Relax, have a good time, and hope for the bees
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I'm not saying that what he did was scummy, what I'm saying is that if he hadn't said anything then I might have had a better chance of surviving the night. Now there is an almost guaranteed certainty that I will die tonight. Unless, of course, we have a doctor-type role. *hopes*

See Ya Space Cowboy...
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
(To the tune of "The Galaxy Song" by Eric Idle)
It seems to me we all agree that Brook is cult, you see,
And as such it's up to us to see he dies.
The keeper of the bridge was so important to the plot,
I'm guessing he's the leader of those guys.
The last cult leader that we found wasn't lynched or burned or drowned,
But had to be dispatched by special skill.
I'd be wary ending day with so much left for us to say,
And until we know that we can make the kill.
I must say it makes me glum to see Sir Robin, my dear chum,
Shuffling right off of this mortal coil.
I'm willing to contend that he fought bravely to the end,
Without his underwear too badly soiled!
It seems to me we all agree that Brook is cult, you see,
And as such it's up to us to see he dies.
The keeper of the bridge was so important to the plot,
I'm guessing he's the leader of those guys.
The last cult leader that we found wasn't lynched or burned or drowned,
But had to be dispatched by special skill.
I'd be wary ending day with so much left for us to say,
And until we know that we can make the kill.
I must say it makes me glum to see Sir Robin, my dear chum,
Shuffling right off of this mortal coil.
I'm willing to contend that he fought bravely to the end,
Without his underwear too badly soiled!
John Hodgman wrote:...while the truth may be stranger than fiction, it is never as strange as lies . . . or as true.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Mullusk, you have a point. As such, I will semi role-claim- I have a daykill, and I'll use it on Brook once he has said his piece. That way we know if he is killable through normal means.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Damnit....
"Yeah I can break necks with my mind." Tristan, Yu-Gi-Oh: The Abridged Version, Episode 31.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Wow, this thing's gone quickly. I'm missing something, how do we know Brooklynx is scum? This game is so complicated, I haven't been following very well. I'm perfectly happy to vote for him if someone can explain things to me.
nightlina wrote:Damn.. if there was a cannon ball thrown for every time someone was wrong on the internet.. well... I don't think we'd have enough cannon balls!
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
peevo wrote:Dammit....
First of all, fixed, second of all, damn what?
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
une see wrote:I'm starting to wonder how many anti-town factions there are...Kipper's death seemed like it was due to the regular mafia, but there are at least 2 other cults. The Knights of Ni, at least, should be gone, right? Since cf died.
Wait, I just noticed something. AS was the killer rabbit, and she killed people who tried to kill her cult-mates. Az tried to kill Brook last night, and was killed by a rabbit. Coincidence? I think not.
Vote: Brooklynxman
SuperTD- this is the crux.
@peevo, just realised you died- minus 5 observation points to me.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I'm too impatient to wait for Brook's explanation.
Vote: Brooklynxman
Also,
Investigate: Bulvox
I have no idea who to investigate so I picked Bulvox at random.
Vote: Brooklynxman
Also,
Investigate: Bulvox
I have no idea who to investigate so I picked Bulvox at random.
Washington: You have to be the most immature soldiers I've ever met.
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
We don't want cultists wandering around cluelessly, do we? Who knows how many rabbits they have.
Vote: Brooklynxman
Vote: Brooklynxman
- une see
- Is my girl
- Posts: 1038
- Joined: Sat Jun 09, 2007 8:31 pm UTC
- Location: a tenuous grip on reality
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Wait, everyone stop. Haven't you been paying attention at all? I actually think it's quite possible that mollusk is right and that Brook cannot be killed through normal means. And until we figure that out, I think a lot of us should unvote. I didn't want to start a bandwagon when I voted for him, I was just pointing out evidence that I thought was pretty damning against Brook. It's not like there's a time limit or anything. I would actually like us to discuss a lot more before we end the day.
Unvote: Brooklynxman
Unvote: Brooklynxman
T.S. Eliot in "The Waste Land" wrote:APRIL is the cruellest month, breeding
Lilacs out of the dead land, mixing
Memory and desire, stirring
Dull roots with spring rain.
- Sir_Elderberry
- Posts: 4206
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2007 6:50 pm UTC
- Location: Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
However, when we tried to kill the Knight who said Ni, we got a hint as to how to actually kill him. So it may still be worth it.
http://www.geekyhumanist.blogspot.com -- Science and the Concerned Voter
Well. You heard him.
Belial wrote:You are the coolest guy that ever cooled.
I reiterate. Coolest. Guy.
Well. You heard him.
- b.i.o
- Green is the loneliest number
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:38 pm UTC
- Location: Hong Kong
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Let Brook talk. Bandwagoning on Day 2 when we have *so* much information is silly. We lose nothing by waiting a little while.
Also, Trumpkin, why are you investigating someone who's practically a confirmed townie?
Also, Trumpkin, why are you investigating someone who's practically a confirmed townie?
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
That's why I suggested me trying to daykill him, and see what happens.
- une see
- Is my girl
- Posts: 1038
- Joined: Sat Jun 09, 2007 8:31 pm UTC
- Location: a tenuous grip on reality
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
b.i.o wrote:Let Brook talk. Bandwagoning on Day 2 when we have *so* much information is silly. We lose nothing by waiting a little while.
Also, Trumpkin, why are you investigating someone who's practically a confirmed townie?
Ugh...Trumpkin. Seriously. You didn't know who to pick?? Anyone but him...
T.S. Eliot in "The Waste Land" wrote:APRIL is the cruellest month, breeding
Lilacs out of the dead land, mixing
Memory and desire, stirring
Dull roots with spring rain.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Brook is scum we know for certain,
Keeper of the evil trench.
Still his powers could be helpful
If he used them on the French.
Rakysh you should try to kill him.
His death would not make me frown,
Still if he should somehow survive,
Maybe he could help the town.
Keeper of the evil trench.
Still his powers could be helpful
If he used them on the French.
Rakysh you should try to kill him.
His death would not make me frown,
Still if he should somehow survive,
Maybe he could help the town.
John Hodgman wrote:...while the truth may be stranger than fiction, it is never as strange as lies . . . or as true.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
mollusk wrote:Rakysh you should try to kill him.
His death would not make me frown,
Still if he should somehow survive,
Maybe he could help the town.
Heh, you've been right about stuff before, but I will wait for him to speak his piece.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
EBWOP: (to the tune of Beethoven's symphony No. 9 Mvt. 4 the "Ode to Joy")
John Hodgman wrote:...while the truth may be stranger than fiction, it is never as strange as lies . . . or as true.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Interesting that there are claims that he's townie, my results say he's scum.
Washington: You have to be the most immature soldiers I've ever met.
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
- b.i.o
- Green is the loneliest number
- Posts: 2519
- Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:38 pm UTC
- Location: Hong Kong
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Results are private? Even if the daycop is public in the first place?
mollusk: the question here is more about motivation. It'd be nice if he were to decide to help the town, but I'm not sure why he'd do so.
mollusk: the question here is more about motivation. It'd be nice if he were to decide to help the town, but I'm not sure why he'd do so.
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
The result being private surprised me too but that's just how things go.
Washington: You have to be the most immature soldiers I've ever met.
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
I don't care for Trump's latest move,
I think it is a scam.
And looking back, it seems to me,
His townhood is a sham.
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
Trumpkin did speculate a bit,
About Kitsune's role.
He then shut up 'til CF's slip
And quick lynch was his goal
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
Now once again he wants to lynch,
Before Brook even talks.
I'm sure first thing tomorrow,
He'll quickly vote Bulvox.
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
I don't care for Trump's latest move,
I think it is a scam.
And looking back, it seems to me,
His townhood is a sham.
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
Trumpkin did speculate a bit,
About Kitsune's role.
He then shut up 'til CF's slip
And quick lynch was his goal
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
Now once again he wants to lynch,
Before Brook even talks.
I'm sure first thing tomorrow,
He'll quickly vote Bulvox.
I'm a minstrel and I'm OK,
I sleep all night and I sing all day!
John Hodgman wrote:...while the truth may be stranger than fiction, it is never as strange as lies . . . or as true.
- Brooklynxman
- Because I'm Awesome
- Posts: 609
- Joined: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:27 pm UTC
- Location: Here
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
I did legitimately intend to use my powers to help root out scum/other cult (at this point trying to hide it is pointless, also, I was the one who suggested peevo kill lan, sorry lan I had a weakness you could exploit if you figured it out (others would be weak against it too) and sorry peevo, how should i have known that would happen).
I am the last of my cult, and cannot recruit (not sure which one of the other two could). So yeah now I have to beat all 18 of you guys to win. Not seeming likely even with my strengths.
Also, I'm not sure who, but someone roleblocked me today, so for today you are safe from me.
Finally, seeing as my win condition is near unreachable and after you guys try the inevitable mass-dk and lynch on me to find it doesn't work, I would be willing to give hunting out scum/any other cult a shot (the knights of Ni started with one knight, right?). Regardless, I cannot recruit so I am not so dangerous to you guys anymore (note, if you doubt this, next person to be questioned by me ask me if I can recruit, I can't recruit).
But yes, I was going to use my powers to help the town, and try and use that as a cover to seem pro-town, or at worst indy. But serious props to whoever got King Arthuer last knight (and I suspect screwed the knights of the round table on their win condition), b/c I am glad to see I am not the only one who had his entire team get ass-raped in terms of possibly winning last night (again, if peevo was still alive, dammit, I had to tell him to kill lan didnt I, still, with lan dead I am safer alive).
Also Bulvox, until I question you you are safe.
Then you are a dead mother *bleep*, you role-outing ass-hat.
I am the last of my cult, and cannot recruit (not sure which one of the other two could). So yeah now I have to beat all 18 of you guys to win. Not seeming likely even with my strengths.
Also, I'm not sure who, but someone roleblocked me today, so for today you are safe from me.
Finally, seeing as my win condition is near unreachable and after you guys try the inevitable mass-dk and lynch on me to find it doesn't work, I would be willing to give hunting out scum/any other cult a shot (the knights of Ni started with one knight, right?). Regardless, I cannot recruit so I am not so dangerous to you guys anymore (note, if you doubt this, next person to be questioned by me ask me if I can recruit, I can't recruit).
But yes, I was going to use my powers to help the town, and try and use that as a cover to seem pro-town, or at worst indy. But serious props to whoever got King Arthuer last knight (and I suspect screwed the knights of the round table on their win condition), b/c I am glad to see I am not the only one who had his entire team get ass-raped in terms of possibly winning last night (again, if peevo was still alive, dammit, I had to tell him to kill lan didnt I, still, with lan dead I am safer alive).
Also Bulvox, until I question you you are safe.
Then you are a dead mother *bleep*, you role-outing ass-hat.
We figure out what all this means, then do something large and violent
The thing about changing the world...once you do it the world's all different.
I'm Angel. I beat the bad guys.
Spoiler:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Yeah Brook that was me. It was a random investigation although the roleblock was a mere side effect in me fulfilling my objectives.
Washington: You have to be the most immature soldiers I've ever met.
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
Grif: Your face is immature.
Washington: Shut up!
- Brooklynxman
- Because I'm Awesome
- Posts: 609
- Joined: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:27 pm UTC
- Location: Here
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Trumpkin wrote:Yeah Brook that was me. It was a random investigation although the roleblock was a mere side effect in me fulfilling my objectives.
Hmph. Alright.
Also, I won't be here tomorrow, and while in other games I have asked for the chance to defend myself on monday here, go ahead. I'd like to be around as I'd find it ammusing, but I don't really have much to defend myself, and its gonna happen anyway (unless you realize you can't kill me that way, or better, realize that waiting a day till someone can counter question me asking if lynching would kill me (I'd recommend that you ask about the recruiting first but thats just me)). Remember I can die from questions if I answer wrong/die. I wouldn't waste a lynch on me, but seeing as I am cult, and I wouldn't listen to me, go right ahead.
I am going to have fun tomorrow laughing my ass off at you. No offense.
We figure out what all this means, then do something large and violent
The thing about changing the world...once you do it the world's all different.
I'm Angel. I beat the bad guys.
Spoiler:
- Brooklynxman
- Because I'm Awesome
- Posts: 609
- Joined: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:27 pm UTC
- Location: Here
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Oh and I might as well post this bit of speculation:
I think the town is a minority. I think the majority of players are either independant or in a SMALL anti-town team (or alone against the town). As such I think all of these roles are going to duke it out.
I think the town is a minority. I think the majority of players are either independant or in a SMALL anti-town team (or alone against the town). As such I think all of these roles are going to duke it out.
We figure out what all this means, then do something large and violent
The thing about changing the world...once you do it the world's all different.
I'm Angel. I beat the bad guys.
Spoiler:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Trumpkin wrote:The result being private surprised me too but that's just how things go.
Oh, I was supposed to make them public? Sorry, I'm still new at the mod thing.
According to the cop, Bulvox is scum.
- une see
- Is my girl
- Posts: 1038
- Joined: Sat Jun 09, 2007 8:31 pm UTC
- Location: a tenuous grip on reality
- Contact:
Re: Monty Python Mafia!: Day 2 - He must have died while carving
Hmmm...well, this is an intriguing turn of events. I didn't see that one coming...I guess I shouldn't have assumed that Bulvox is town, since he would want to screw over the various cults if he is scum. Although mollusk doesn't trust the investigation, and I feel like he has a lot more information than the rest of us do. mollusk, do you have any specific reason you don't think the investigation is accurate, or was it just because Vieto hadn't yet posted the result publicly?
Because if Bulvox is scum, I think we should lynch him today instead of Brook. The more I think about it, the more I think Brook can't be lynched or daykilled. But that also seems really overpowered....At least with cf, there was "it" to kill him.
Because if Bulvox is scum, I think we should lynch him today instead of Brook. The more I think about it, the more I think Brook can't be lynched or daykilled. But that also seems really overpowered....At least with cf, there was "it" to kill him.
T.S. Eliot in "The Waste Land" wrote:APRIL is the cruellest month, breeding
Lilacs out of the dead land, mixing
Memory and desire, stirring
Dull roots with spring rain.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Mark_Cangila and 16 guests