When I first read through the thread I thought it looked like PS was saying things that didn't make sense for him to know, but looking back they just look more like he was making some guesses that I misinterpreted.
The only thing I really found that seemed scummy was just this, which isn't very scummy at that.
PossibleSloth wrote:Yea, we do need to lynch someone at some point.
But while I was looking for the quote, I ran into
PossibleSloth wrote:Seems to me false-claiming just opens a big water-muddying bag of WIFOM worms on the game (I may be mixing metaphors here) and serves to confuse those of us looking for viruses.
PossibleSloth wrote:I'll see if I can clear some of this up.
Yesterday I was in touch with keeneal and S_E. At this point, I wasn't sure that I could trust keeneal because of all the info fishing and I was halfway convinced S_E was a virus. I was asked to claim and I put out a false-claim with a fake ability to see if it would trip up the viruses. It was probably a stupid plan but I really didn't want to roleclaim to two people I was on the fence about. When Keeneal responded, I was pretty sure both he and S_E were town but unfortunately this was after the hammer and I couldn't respond. Sorry for lying to you Keeneal, Sir_Elderberry, and I hope you understand.
I'm inclined to trust the S_E, CF group more than VZ. If he's a virus, odds are the PCR thing is a way to lead the lynch away from himself and protect his own ass.
I think its reasonable to not want to say your real role if you think someone your talking to might be scum, but it still feels a bit off.
I'm not sure what to think about anyone else at this point, but I am suspicious of anyone who jumped on the PS bandwagon so quickly.