By all means agree/disagree as you see fit, I am trying to get a consolidated view of the game.
Based on an assumption of 3 Scum, 1 Indy and 9 Town:
1 of the NK will start with 1 x Scum, but then automatically drift from Scum to Scum, as they are lynched/NK'd, or even Switched.
I am assuming that 1 of the NK will disappear when all Scum are dead.
1 of the NK is definitely the Indy, who really has to be a SK, as a Vig would/could win with Town. Even without the NK ability, they would still have to survive.
Would the game end, if all Scum are dead and the SK/Vig/Survivor was without the NK?
Is the 2nd NK skill a 'floating' skill, ie assuming the 1st NK MUST stay with Scum, the 2nd NK may not stay with the same person?
I notice that we do NOT have Doctors!
If we have a SK/Vig, then I suspect that he must have been informed in their role PM.
Whether he starts with the NK or not is another issue, but I suspect so.
Probable starting conditions could be:
SK with NK
1 x Scum with NK
1 x Scum with Switcher
1 x Scum with Mirror
Town would have:
2 x Switchers
1 x Mirror
2 x Blockers
2 x Cops
1 x Watcher
1 x Vanilla
Will the Watcher be told the targets action and/or action on them, and/or targets' target?
If a Blocker targets a Mirror, then a Cop on the Mirror would turn out correct, ie NOT a reflection.
I can see where a Switcher targetting the Scum NK, will get a Vanilla in return and the NK is moved to the next Scum in turn, or the Switcher getting the 2nd Scums' trait..
If you are the Cop, I see you getting a Scum/Town result PM.
If you are the Switcher, you get no return PM.
If you are the Mirror, you get no return PM.
If you are the Blocker, you get no return PM.
If you are the Watcher, you will get a result PM (see above)
Should everyone 'COP' the first Night, so that they can identify if they are a Cop?
If everyone was to show their result on D2, then we end up with 13 results, all showing Town, because if any result was turned up as Scum, then we must have a Real Cop + Scum, or it is Scum, so 2 lynches later, we would be down 1 x Scum.
Perceived Night-Actions ordering:
roband wrote:Sorry, my quietness is partly due to a busy weekend and partly due to my equal-first game being so complicated.
I think we're all going to know a lot more after a night period, so would it be worth going for a non-lynch on D1? Unless someone admits being scum orientated, anyway!
I'll take this as NEWBIE talk, as it is almost always beneficial to lynch, if nothing else, it may help clear up WINE.