It can't be anybody but VZ or FAOT.
Scum wouldn't kill their own with only two left, even if it raised suspicion and confusion.
Mav has to have the NK (no one counter claimed, and there was
a non-scum-based kill), I am Trooper Green.
There practically has to be a doctor; at a 1:3 scum:town ratio, it'd be stupid for scum to just not kill.
I don't see VZ counterclaiming doctor - only saying that FAOT isn't.
VectorZero wrote:Let's just run through the claims. Mav=Dignam. If shes lying, then either Dignam isn't in the game or someone else is lying too.
If she is not Dignam, how would she know about Town gaining another NK? She is definitely Dignam.
VectorZero wrote:Cjdum=Trooper Green. If he's lying, then he somehow predicted early in the game that there were multiple Troopers.
Exactly. How do you expect I would just know?
VectorZero wrote:VZ=Trooper Brown. If I'm lying then the canon trooper is not in the game. Also, I would have to be scum.
If you aren't the doctor, then you must be scum. Or, FAoT is extremely stupid scum, which I doubt is the case. Also, see the italicized bit for what you seemingly neglected to say.
VectorZero wrote:FAOT=Madden. If you're lying, then you withheld the night kill. That seems the simplest explanation.
It is the simplest explanation - if he is scum. If he isn't, then he protected the scum kill. Even more simple than your explanation.
I will also wait for some info from Mav before placing my vote on VectorZero, but he currently seems to be neglecting simple facts to twist the facts to his argument - which leads him to being the most scummy candidate.