My case for BF being town is this:
Misnomer wrote:Control of the kill decision will be randomly distributed to one of you each night
@a-wan: You are misconstruing some of the mechanics of the game. The one to execute the Mafia kill is determined randomly by the mod.
I'm sorry, but this just doesn't seem like he's trying to sew confusion. I think he honestly believed at the time that Mafia didn't get to decide who executed the kill. I truly believe he's not mafia. We know he's not WW.
And I think I've been boneheaded about one assumption I made. First of all, I'm back to believing very strongly that roband and Lataro are mafia. Lataro will say that it's because they are now voting for me, but I've been accusing them before they were accusing me. They've only jumped on me because I accused them. Since Lataro is so fond of making pretend quotes about people, I'll do the same for him.
Lataro: "How dare you accuse me! I gave you a pass yesterday! You're supposed to like me and hang on every word I say! Now I will accuse you and get everyone to lynch you!"
Anyways, the boneheaded assumption I made is that mafia would make killing WW a priority. Given that I think roband and Lataro are GoP's partners, I can see why they would think that GoP had the weakest power. Additionally, since they thought that WW would likely be targeting GoP, they thought that at least they could use him to deliver the kill since his power would be the easiest to disguise. Either he's dead or he says he copped someone and they weren't WW. Easy.
Meanwhile roband blocks BF which BF can confirm, so he's not the killer. Lataro's use of poison will show that he's not the killer tomorrow. Only catch is that now roband will have to make the kill tonight, so no one will be RBed.
If people don't believe me, go back through the thread and read how Lataro and roband have defended each other. They barely give any reasons.
Lataro: "Can't be roband. He's a puppy so BACK OFF!"
roband: "Nah, I just don't think Lataro's scum because...well, because!"
Also, roband is not making a very strong effort at scum hunting. He put Ibarra and BF together. If he had been truly scum hunting, he never
would have put them together. He was looking for someone he could label as scum. He picked Ibarra because I was saying that he, Lataro, and Ibarra were candidates, and he wasn't about to pick Lataro.
So, as I see it, if you choose me, then tomorrow I'm dead, BF is dead, whoever else they choose to kill is dead, and whoever WW chooses to kill is dead. I'll flip town and so will BF, and you could be at 2-2-1, worst case.
If you believe I'm scum, then worst case tomorrow is 3-2-1. I'm not saying vote Lataro only because it's the more cautious path. I'm saying that you should vote for Lataro because there's a good case against him and roband, but if you're on the fence, kill Lataro today and me tomorrow. Chances are pretty good though that if we lynch Lataro today, I'll be killed in the night anyway.
The one piece of good news is that I don't think we have to worry about roband's RB tonight. He can't claim to RB Lataro because BF will be dead. If he claims anyone else, they'll know.
If it doesn't happen like that, lynch me tomorrow.