The great photon disappearence act!

Moderators: gmalivuk, Moderators General, Prelates

The great photon disappearence act!

As I understand it a photon:
-always travels at c.
-has no rest-mass but it has some mass when it has energy. (in accordance to m=e/c^2)
-it's frequency is also related to it's energy.
but I'm far from an expert in this field.

Now if one were to take a light source and a gravitational source.
Let's take a lightbulb and a black hole.
(as a black hole is a point mass and a lightbulb emits light in all directions-we'd also need an extension cord for the lightbulb)
if said lightbulb were to fall towards the black hole, it's no stretch of the imagination to say that there would atleast 1 photon whose velocity vector is direcly opposite to the gravitational vector.
Would it then continue to move away from the black hole, losing energy as it did and then dissapear(as it would lose all it's properties)? or would it lose no energy at all and escape the black hole?

The first scenario seems to violate conservation of energy (unless the field absorbs it).
The second one, to me, seems plausible but as I said I'm certainly no expert in this field so I suspect I might be wrong as it leads to a possible violation of the definition of a black hole.

So, assuming I am wrong (as I probablly am), where did I go wrong? are my assumptions wrong or am I missing something important?
"I gotta have a little bit of Orange juice
I gotta have.. my.. Orange juice!
I gotta have.. my.. Orange juice!
Juice juice juice juice juice juice juice juice
"

~Richard Feynman

Red Rule

Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Apr 29, 2010 11:24 am UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

In the event that a photon is inside the event horizon of the black hole, something rather weird happens: the photon hits the black hole, and contributes its energy to it. If the lightbulb is not inside the event horizon, then the photon escapes with some non-zero energy. (The rest of which is converted into gravitational potential energy.)
...And that is how we know the Earth to be banana-shaped.

Robert'); DROP TABLE *;

Posts: 633
Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2008 6:46 pm UTC
Location: in ur fieldz

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

I am intriguied, but after a little reading I fear that further questioning will result in me having a terrible headache.
So many things to study, so little time.
"I gotta have a little bit of Orange juice
I gotta have.. my.. Orange juice!
I gotta have.. my.. Orange juice!
Juice juice juice juice juice juice juice juice
"

~Richard Feynman

Red Rule

Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Apr 29, 2010 11:24 am UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Red Rule wrote:if said lightbulb were to fall towards the black hole, it's no stretch of the imagination to say that there would atleast 1 photon whose velocity vector is direcly opposite to the gravitational vector.
Once the lightbulb has crossed the event horizon this is no longer true, all paths lead to the singularity, just as all paths for us lead into the future.
Quantropy.org: a repository to which anyone can submit an academic paper
quantropy

Posts: 92
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2008 6:55 pm UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Red Rule wrote: or would it lose no energy at all and escape the black hole?

A photon that is emitted outside the event horizon in the right direction will escape, but it will lose energy, in the form of being redshifted. So your nice blue lightbulb will appear to become red as it approaches the black hole.
Ik ben niet koppig, ik heb gewoon gelijk.

Roĝer

Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Oct 05, 2008 9:36 pm UTC
Location: Many worlds, but mostly Copenhagen.

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

So what happens to photons that are emitted away from the black hole inside the event horizon?

Levi

Posts: 1296
Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2008 1:12 am UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

There is no "away from the black hole" inside the event horizon. All paths lead toward the singularity.
(defun fibs (n &optional (a 1) (b 1)) (take n (unfold '+ a b)))

Xanthir
My HERO!!!

Posts: 3988
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:49 am UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Or to put it another way, they might be going "away" at c, but space is moving inwards at greater than c, so ultimatly they move inwards anyways. They just move inwards as slowly as possible.
Wolydarg wrote:That was like a roller coaster of mathematical reasoning. Problems! Solutions! More problems!

****************Signature Dehosted, New Signature Under Construction************************

Antimony-120

Posts: 831
Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 4:16 am UTC
Location: Wherever you can look - wherever there's a fight, so hungry people can eat.

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

It's rather difficult to visualize, but spacetime is still 4 dimensional within the event horizon, but the radial direction now becomes the time dimension. That means there must be another space dimension orthogonal to the two spherical angle dimensions. That's presumably the direction the photon travels in, but it's no longer a radial direction - I would think that it has the same status as the spherical angle dimensions.
Quantropy.org: a repository to which anyone can submit an academic paper
quantropy

Posts: 92
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2008 6:55 pm UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Inside a black hole...

Well, what most people don't realise is this: Inside an event horizon there is no such thing as "outwards."

Once you have fallen inside, every direction is towards the singularity.

You have to travel backwards in time to get out.
EvanED wrote:be aware that when most people say "regular expression" they really mean "something that is almost, but not quite, entirely unlike a regular expression"

language blag

MHD

Posts: 630
Joined: Fri Mar 20, 2009 8:21 pm UTC
Location: Denmark

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Roĝer wrote:
Red Rule wrote: or would it lose no energy at all and escape the black hole?

A photon that is emitted outside the event horizon in the right direction will escape, but it will lose energy, in the form of being redshifted. So your nice blue lightbulb will appear to become red as it approaches the black hole.

Also important to not is that from your perspective the light-bulb will take longer to reach the event horizon then it would under Newtonian mechanics. So while you see a lower energy of light you see it for longer.
So if you don't believe you have a cat, that's actually evidence that you have an infinite cat.

Posts: 451
Joined: Sun Oct 19, 2008 5:28 pm UTC
Location: Space Florida

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

MHD wrote:Inside a black hole...

Well, what most people don't realise is this: Inside an event horizon there is no such thing as "outwards."

Once you have fallen inside, every direction is towards the singularity.

You have to travel backwards in time to get out.

But you can't observe yourself to have fallen inside the event horizon - it seems to shrink away beneath you, and there will always (well, until you die) in fact be a direction you can point to that to you appears to be 'out' even after you are inside the horizon according to a distant observer.

... random thought, what would happen if the Schwarzschild radius of the observable universe became larger than the observable universe?
All Shadow priest spells that deal Fire damage now appear green.
Big freaky cereal boxes of death.

WarDaft

Posts: 1538
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2009 3:16 pm UTC

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

WarDaft wrote:... random thought, what would happen if the Schwarzschild radius of the observable universe became larger than the observable universe?

You'd be in a closed universe, doomed to collapse to a singularity in finite time.
ATCG wrote:
Tass wrote:Nice to see another person sharing my views of quantum mechanics. Use Occam's razor, cut out the wavefunction collapse.
I had to chuckle after reading this, then noticing your location. Surely you risk being burned at the stake as a heretic.

Tass

Posts: 1699
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2008 2:21 pm UTC
Location: Niels Bohr Institute, Copenhagen.

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Tass wrote:
WarDaft wrote:... random thought, what would happen if the Schwarzschild radius of the observable universe became larger than the observable universe?

You'd be in a closed universe, doomed to collapse to a singularity in finite time.

But the calculation for the Schwarzschild radius doesn't include dark energy/cosmological constant, which at such low densities becomes very relevant.
Ik ben niet koppig, ik heb gewoon gelijk.

Roĝer

Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Oct 05, 2008 9:36 pm UTC
Location: Many worlds, but mostly Copenhagen.

Re: The great photon disappearence act!

Roĝer wrote:
Tass wrote:
WarDaft wrote:... random thought, what would happen if the Schwarzschild radius of the observable universe became larger than the observable universe?

You'd be in a closed universe, doomed to collapse to a singularity in finite time.

But the calculation for the Schwarzschild radius doesn't include dark energy/cosmological constant, which at such low densities becomes very relevant.

Sure.
ATCG wrote:
Tass wrote:Nice to see another person sharing my views of quantum mechanics. Use Occam's razor, cut out the wavefunction collapse.
I had to chuckle after reading this, then noticing your location. Surely you risk being burned at the stake as a heretic.

Tass

Posts: 1699
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2008 2:21 pm UTC
Location: Niels Bohr Institute, Copenhagen.