Well, I hope you guys didn't want to win this game, if you're relying on my analysis :/. All I can say is props to whoever of phlip and DL is the remaining scum for playing pretty well the whole game, although, as infina didn't name them on D1 and there was a lot of fuss surrounding infina's rotten play on D1 and D2, there were plenty of places for them to hide. It was easy on D1 to just jump on infina's bandwagon and then on D2 any arguments for BigNose or TwoFry were not seen as out of place.
I've read the whole thread and made notes, and things that stood out include:
DL not hammering infina on D1 - he had the chance, at the time we were at hammer-1, but he didn't hammer, and then it got a bit messy and infina hammered himself, in the end.
Neither phlip or DL voting for TwoFry on D2. I was hoping one of them would have, and the one that didn't might be our scum. However, that does make two for two non-votes from DL.
On day 2, DarkLoink did some pretty good analysis of people. Almost everyone, I think. However, he found BigNose scummy and TwoFry townie.
phlip also did some good analysis, however was possibly clutching at straws calling meatyochre scummy-seeming.
phlip then on both D2 and D3 mentioned how scummy BigNose was seeming with all his voting and FoSing of people out of mostly OMGUS. Which I think is probably fair enough, but could be scum trying to push more onto BigNose than is warranted in order to try and secure a lynch. On D3 he then votes BigNose.
Misnomer notes that while DL has been inactive in game, he has been online.
After DL got modprodded, he posted a post with not that much content and promptly disappeared again.
Going with my theory of not wanting to mod-kill the last scum and end the game it might have actually been DL that prompted Dr Ug to start looking for replacements, that is, until he (kinda) started posting again.
DL has not voted the whole game and has lurked a lot.
I'm leaning towards DL being the last scum. He found TwoFry to be townie in his analysis D2, and BigNose to be scummy, supporting the opposite of what was true, and pushing people in that direction. He hasn't voted at all the whole game, most noticeably not hammering infina and saying he was waiting to post more content he never posted. A lot of his posts were short, saying he would post more content later, only for that later post to be largely the same. He has actively lurked.
I'm not great at analysis and this is my first game, but that is my opinion of the situation. Phlip did some scummy things, but he has actively posted content the whole game, where DL has been a lot more conservative with his posts and activity.