The problem is knowing someones role or power doesn't give indication to their alignment. At this moment, I'm inclined towards a Webby lynch today for a few reasons. The first is that he put us at a 2-2-2 lynch yesterday, which in a bastardry game is never a good scenario. Second, that's a very 'safe' play in that if a town player had ended up being lynched he would have looked less suspicous for not having the deciding vote. Also, at 2-2-2, either two people would have had to removed votes, one person would have had to change votes or Wei would have had to put his vote down. It's an incredibly dangerous situation the more I think about it. Third, the vote was for Lorenz, which if hadn't been a draw might have resulted in another NL.
Generally I'm not happy with your voting strategies towards the end of the day, Webby. Thinking more into it, had a vote change had to occur (say Wei hadn't logged on) then it would have been more likely that Lorenz or Lataro would have been lynched as e_e wouldn't have removed her vote so either me or Lorenz would have had to change to Lataro or Lorenz. Basically, what the hell were you thinking Webby?
I was thinking that it was more than 10 hours until the deadline, and therefore plenty of time for the situation to change, especially as there were two people who hadn't voted yet (weiyaoli and Ibarra), who could make the decision - I don't think a tying vote that long before the deadline is a problem. Basically, I was the fourth person to vote out of six. I was also thinking, as turned out to be the case, that cjdrum's play was not scummy so much as it was strange, and that I didn't think he was any more or less likely to be scum than the average player. Basically I wanted to test whether Lorenz was actually lynch-immune, or whether it was limited-shot, because I'm pretty sure limited-shot immunity could be that he's the only scum in the game, while permanent lynch immunity could mean townie, although I would have expected him to be nightkilled by now.
With no nightkills, and only a jester lynched, we're effectively where we were at the start of the game. I still want to lynch Lorenz.
Btw two more possibilities:
- weiyaoli is scum who can either roleblock or kill each night, but not both.
- FOAT is scum and withheld the kill because it would look pretty suspicious if there wasn't a nightkill when he was roleblocked, and there was when he wasn't.
I reckon it's most likely either weiyaoli's option 2, or my last possibility.