Logic Poll

A forum for good logic/math puzzles.

Moderators: jestingrabbit, Moderators General, Prelates

Logic Poll

Here is a poll where your answer and the answers of everyone else will affect the correct answer. After a short time, I will release the results

http://tinyurl.com/3qb8jbf
liniarc

Posts: 10
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 3:46 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

liniarc wrote:Here is a poll where your answer and the answers of everyone else will affect the correct answer. After a short time, I will release the results

http://tinyurl.com/3qb8jbf

Neat. I’d really like to see graphs of the answers over time.
Small Government Liberal

Qaanol

Posts: 2398
Joined: Sat May 09, 2009 11:55 pm UTC

Re: Logic Poll

Looks neat. Question: one of the questions asks "What % of people...". Do you want an answer in the form of "x%" or just "x" (e.g. if I think the correct answer is 101%, should I write "101" or "101%" in the box)?

Blatm

Posts: 638
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 1:43 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

Blatm wrote:Looks neat. Question: one of the questions asks "What % of people...". Do you want an answer in the form of "x%" or just "x" (e.g. if I think the correct answer is 101%, should I write "101" or "101%" in the box)?

You should write it as x (Without the percent sign)

Also, If anyone else has any other ideas for questions, I'll add them. I'll post results about once every 50 times.
It's interesting since having everyone knowing the answers won't make it any easier.
liniarc

Posts: 10
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 3:46 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

I can't wait for the results, seems to be very interesting
SirWhy

Posts: 4
Joined: Sun Aug 14, 2011 11:14 pm UTC

Re: Logic Poll

Well for the results after 50 votes.
The format for the answer will be:
Consider whole numbers from 1 to 10, what is the LEAST picked number when asked this question?
Spoiler:
1 5 10%
2 3 6%
3 4 8%
4 4 8%
5 5 10%
6 4 8%
7 5 10%
8 5 10%
9 3 6%
10 11 22%
Correct answers in this case: 2 and 9

Consider whole numbers from 1 to 10, what is the MOST picked number when asked this question?

Spoiler:
1 8 16%
2 0 0%
3 3 6%
4 1 2%
5 6 12%
6 0 0%
7 28 57%
8 1 2%
9 0 0%
10 2 4%
Correct answer in this case: 7

What % of answers to this question will be correct? (Round to the nearest percent)
Spoiler:
0 4 8%
1 4 8%
2 3 6%
3 3 6%
4 2 4%
5 4 8%
6 1 2%
7 1 2%
8 2 4%
9 2 4%
10 5 10%
11 1 2%
12 1 2%
15 1 2%
17 1 2%
24 1 2%
25 1 2%
30 2 4%
33 1 2%
42 1 2%
45 1 2%
50 2 4%
62 1 2%
67 1 2%
77 1 2%
80 1 2%
87 1 2%
100 1 2%
Correct answers in this case: 4% and 10%

What's the second largest integer answered
Spoiler:
A(g64,g63)
1E+121
1E+114
1E+49
1E+37
1E+33
1E+18
1.23435E+11
4294967295
999999998
99999998
1048576
1000000
999998
999988
750000
586123
50000
9001
7001
5632
4300
1000
900
516
487
432
152
101
101
100
100
99
99
98
78
56
50
50
12
9
9
7
5
3
3
0

Most people think the answer to this is true.
Spoiler:
True 33 66%
False 16 32%
liniarc

Posts: 10
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 3:46 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

liniarc wrote:What % of answers to this question will be correct? (Round to the nearest percent)
Spoiler:
0 4 8%
1 4 8%
2 3 6%
3 3 6%
4 2 4%
5 4 8%
6 1 2%
7 1 2%
8 2 4%
9 2 4%
10 5 10%
11 1 2%
12 1 2%
15 1 2%
17 1 2%
24 1 2%
25 1 2%
30 2 4%
33 1 2%
42 1 2%
45 1 2%
50 2 4%
62 1 2%
67 1 2%
77 1 2%
80 1 2%
87 1 2%
100 1 2%
Correct answers in this case: 4% and 10%

Spoiler:
So what you're saying is, 7/50 answers were correct. Therefore 14% was the correct answer. Therefore 0% was the correct answer. Therefore 8% was the correct answer. Therefore 4% was the correct answer. Hurrah, equilibrium has been reached!

That was fun!
Goodbye

Posts: 847
Joined: Thu Jun 16, 2011 6:36 pm UTC

Re: Logic Poll

"What % of answers to this question will be correct? (Round to the nearest percent)" is a strange question. Who defines that "correct" means "gets that amount of answers"?

-> "What % of answers to this question will be the same as your input?"

Very nice idea.
mfb

Posts: 824
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 7:48 pm UTC

Re: Logic Poll

Well, I was correct on questions 2, 3 and 5. Question 4 is nearly impossible without an upper bound on the integers, and would quickly become trivial with such a bound. I was so close to getting Question 1 right, though. Maybe in another 50 answers I'll have it...

I'm still pretty happy with my score of 3/5. Can anyone beat that?

Posts: 2195
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 12:35 pm UTC
Location: 한국 창원

Re: Logic Poll

I got 1, 2 and 5 right. Possibly 3 as well, can't remember what I put but it was around the 2-4% mark I think.
Thisisnotasmile

Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Nov 12, 2009 12:59 pm UTC

Re: Logic Poll

that last question is easy.

4=5

Posts: 2068
Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 3:02 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

And for results again.
What is the LEAST picked number when asked this question?
Spoiler:
1 23 17%
2 13 10%
3 13 10%
4 9 7%
5 14 10%
6 6 4%
7 12 9%
8 15 11%
9 10 7%
10 21 15%

What is the MOST picked number when asked this question?
Spoiler:
1 14 10%
2 3 2%
3 9 7%
4 5 4%
5 9 7%
6 4 3%
7 70 51%
8 5 4%
9 1 1%
10 16 12%

What % of answers to this question will be correct? (Round to the nearest percent)
Spoiler:
0 8 5.8%
1 9 6.6%
2 7 5.1%
3 6 4.4%
4 9 6.6%
5 7 5.1%
6 2 1.5%
7 3 2.2%
8 2 1.5%
9 2 1.5%
10 18 13.1%
11 1 0.7%
12 1 0.7%
14 1 0.7%
15 6 4.4%
17 2 1.5%
20 5 3.6%
24 1 0.7%
25 2 1.5%
30 5 3.6%
33 1 0.7%
36 1 0.7%
42 1 0.7%
45 1 0.7%
50 16 11.7%
56 1 0.7%
62 2 1.5%
67 1 0.7%
70 2 1.5%
75 3 2.2%
77 1 0.7%
80 1 0.7%
83 1 0.7%
87 1 0.7%
100 7 5.1%

What's the second largest integer answered?
Spoiler:
A(g64,g63)
5x10^10^10^10^10^10^10^10^10
10^10^100-1

Most people think the answer to this is true.
Spoiler:
True 102 75%
False 33 24%

The second question is now very easily answered. As such, it will be removed.
The third question, as said by mfb, is slightly confusing. It will be replaced with "What % of answers to this question will be the same as your input?"
The fourth question will be removed. By nature, only one person can be correct.
The fifth question, like the 2nd question is very easily answered. It will be replaced with "Most people think the answer to this is FALSE."

"Consider integers from 1 to 10, What number will be 1 more than the most picked number? (If it's 10, it will loop to 1)"
"How many times was your answer chosen? (i.e. 42 people chose the number 42)"
liniarc

Posts: 10
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 3:46 am UTC

Re: Logic Poll

I don't think "How many times was your answer chosen? (i.e. 42 people chose the number 42)" should be included because it depends heavily on how many times the quiz has been taken. All the other ideas are very cool.

Blatm

Posts: 638
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 1:43 am UTC