It's fine, but not foolproof, because you assume you would have been blocked because it was obvious who you were going to target. You had to assume. With Misnomer, you didn't. So why did you not switch to a from-your-point-of-view certain mafioso? Am I missing something?
This is pretty much the only argument that REALLY makes me think they are both scum.
If I'm scum, then wouldn't I know that Misnomer got it right and just follow suit?
Maybe... Unless (what Sruixan said) or Misnomer is also scum, and you thought their claim was unlikely. That way it would appear as if you are a town/scum pair, saving one of you.
...I really need to stop making these posts in bed, because I never get the chance to actually sit there and think about it. As far as I'm concerned, though, despite Lorenz saying that receiving notification of a failed action is "farfetched", I'm wondering what I would do in EP's shoes and to be honest unless I fancied having a handful of rather bemused people asking whether or not I forgot their action, I'd probably tell them. It's the sort of info you'd think we'd oughta get as well; Minsomer would never have known that his supposed kill had actually failed if he hadn't been told, given that he targeted the otherwise deceased jayhsu. I probably should stop trying to read the mod's mind, but at least you can see where I'm coming from, right?
I guess it's possible. It's quite simple actually, someone's kill is bound to be unsuccessful in the same way as Misnomer's was, so it's a testable claim that we can wait on answers before playing with Misnomer's fate.
The lack of input from softchews is beginning to get annoying
I'm not one to talk, after my lack of input day one, but it Is pretty much who we're waiting for. Prod?
If I'm scum then:
1. Misnomer is town
2. Lorenz is town
3. softchews is town
4. Sruixan is town (he didn't say this, of course, but it's implied)
On the other hand, if you're town then
I'm likely scum, so is softchews and misnomer. It would make the town team (assuming 4 again)
Sruixan, Webby, Weiyaoli, a-wan. The lynch on day 1
more_people: 6 (Not A Raptor, Sruixan, softchews, Misnomer, Lorenz, Ibarra)
would mean that Scum was lynched, with only 2 town voting them..... even when I was such a good candidate for scum to lynch me? (Right... this last part involves me knowing I'm town but whatever) It's not impossible but it's quite unlikely in my most humble opinion.