BoomFrog wrote:I am having a hard time decided between AS and Angua as the 2nd scum.
Er, actually, BF, it shouldn't be that hard for you. Like, at all. See, I'm William from Danny the savior of the world. My power is a roleblock that blocks all aspects of the role (including mafia kills). Last night, I roleblocked Angua. No night kill went through.
Now, lets assume that I, Angua, and you are town. Both me and Angua are out of commission, and your power does nothing to prevent the night kill. Thus, the night kill should have gone through. However, that doesn't match the facts.
Now, lets assume that I, AS, and you are town and Angua carries out the night kill. In that case, my roleblock would have prevented the night kill, which would have ultimately resulted in no night kill going through. That matches the facts.
Now, lets assume that I, AS, and you are town and webby carried out the night kill on someone other than AS. In that case, the night kill should have gone though. However, that doesn't match the facts.
Finally, lets assume that I, AS and you are town and webby carried out the night kill on AS. In that case, the night kill should not have gone though. That matches the facts.
So, ultimately BF, if you think I'm town it follows that AS must be town, because a webby/AS scum team makes no sense given last nights result.
I, however, am not as confident as I was about BF/webby. I think its fair to say one of them is scum, but I'm not sure which one. I am, however, quite confident that Angua is scum. So, here is what I propose: we lynch Angua today, and I roleblock Webby tonight. If no night kill goes through, we lynch webby. If a night kill goes through, we lynch BF. If we lynch webby and he flips town, I roleblock BF during the night, and me and AS lynch him D4. I know I'm relying on AS being town, but at this point that seems like a reasonably safe assumption to make. Does that plan sound good to everyone?