You mean they come more experienced than BoomFrog? *quivers in fear*
My point was that the knowledge that Scum could only neighbour-chat wasn't just the observations of a more experienced playe. If, for example, a complete newby like me was the only one who didn't believe it then that could be discounted. The fact that BF was in agreeance meant I felt justified in not knowing that nightchat=power. I may have been wrong.
Of course it's possible that roband was just going on the 'chat between neighbours only' in the sign up thread. It's equally possible, considering his confidence (ie. lack of spec) in something which was later confirmed but only scum would previously know means that he slipped up as scum. As I've never played with him before I'm in a poor place to judge the probability of this.
So now to quote snipe a quote snipe:
I don't like that this is just parrotting me.
He says something that broadly agrees with you. He isn't parroting, just laying out a point and justifying it. If we're not allowed to form the same opinions as others then this game'll go nowhere.
Seriously? I don't think it would be. It wouldn't make it obvious who scum are, until at least D3, by which point the scum have probably won or lost anyway.
I'm in agreeance with mn. Limiting Nk to two choices/night would neuter the macias role.
You are not the mod, it's not impossible.
...and that reads, intentionally or not, as one of the most infantile arguments around. mn offers an opinion and you reply with the "Your not God, you don't know
So you want to keep your mind open, but the whole post you made is about you're certain something isn't in place.
The only ones who know for sure are scum. And they're likely to want to misdirect us.
And finally this, about a post chockablock with qualifiers and ifs.
To me this doesn't read as a structured take down of a fawlty arguement, rather as a poorly formed attack.
I apologise for grouping it with the later vote but there did appear to be a connection between the two. I can see how the later would be a valid tactic.
To everyone: is it worth discussing what we think power roles should do. We don't need to roleclaim, just say something like 'I think any doctor-like role should target so-and-so'.