Moderators: Moderators General, Magistrates, Prelates
Monika wrote:English has some weird traditions about shortening some common names:
Richard -> Dick
Robert -> Bob
William -> Bill
tsarna wrote:Monika wrote:English has some weird traditions about shortening some common names:
Richard -> Dick
Robert -> Bob
William -> Bill
There are more obvious shortenings (William -> Will, Robert->Rob)
I have often thought that, if Will is short for William and Rob is short for Robert, that the full forms of Bill and Bob should be Billiam and Bobert.
We don’t care how it works—we just want to know if we can break it.
Monika wrote:dmm wrote:No, YOU are the one missing MY point. I never said what you are accusing me of saying. All the AAAHHHH THUMPY WOOBLE HARRRRRPINK!! in the world can't turn a name like Female or Shithead into an acceptable name. When a parent makes up a name off the top of his/her head, or uses a word he/she didn't understand just because it sounds nice, and it turns out to be a disaster name, then that's funny. And if the name-giver refuses to change the name once the flaw is pointed out, THAT is evidence of gross stupidity, and THAT is the problem.
You still didn't get it. No child has ever been named Shithead, Shi-thead or Shi'thead. White people made this up. "Look, black parents are so stupid!" Please read the explanation in this 2007 Snopes article (not the same one as the Le-a one) http://www.snopes.com/racial/language/names.asp
So, my wife's a liar, huh? Nice. You refuse to believe anything that contradicts your personal "reality."Monika wrote:I also have doubts about girls being named Female. It's not a terrible name and not as unlikely as Shi['|-]thead, but I have never seen proof beyond "I knew someone with this name", which could very well mean "a friend told me s/he knew a woman with this name", which in turn could mean "a friend who read this in a chain mail claimed s/he knew a woman with this name".
Monika wrote:dmm wrote:but you might want to read the book Freakonomics anyway.
I have read Freakonomics. You have read Freakonomics. You may want to reread it or reassess the conclusions you drew from it. Freakonomics says: Black parents are likely to give their daughters unique names. Black parents are also likely to give their daughters word names like "Chastity". I have to reread the book to see what exactly it said about poor parents. As far as I remember Freakonomics did not compare the rate of unusual child names for black rich parents, black poor parents, white rich parents and white poor parents.
Adults with black-sounding names have disadvantages later in life. Studies showed that the same job application and resume with a black-sounding name is rated worse by white potential employers than the exact same application and resume with a white-sounding name. So what conclusion should be drawn from this? Should black people go to job interviews with a bag over their head and gloves?
Ronsonic wrote:Beyond the Idiocracy-like product names there are options like Cosmolene and Linolea.
Some years ago there was a study that, according to the headlines, showed widespread racism in hiring. The study used a bunch of recent college graduate resumes off the internet and randomly matched them to racially identifiable names from hospital records from the appropriate time. And yes, overall, the "black" names got fewer calls from employers. What was interesting was reading the actual results that showed black employers just as discriminating / discriminatory as white. Then when you get to the raw numbers - Ebony did as well as Heather, it was Quan'esha who couldn't get date and was dragging down the average for the side. Same for the guys, nobody was calling D'Andre while Tyrone was hanging with Tyler and Jeremy.
Now maybe it's still unfair, employers can't know that Quintalisha is ghetto, but they can be pretty sure her mom was.
GreatLimmick wrote:One of the worst I've seen in real life is a guy I know who named his son Seven. That's going to get confusing in a few years.
mcv wrote:Fire Brns wrote:John is a shortening of Jonathan.
Are you really sure? I was under the impression that John was the English version of Johannes, as in the apostle. I never had the impression Johannes and Jonathan were the same name.Jack is the dimunitive of the archaic Jakin.
Is it not short for James, which seems to be the English version of Jacobus (again an apostle), also Jacob, Jaap or Jacques in some languages?
If not, then how did the English names of the biblical apostles get so messed up?
dmm wrote:Monika wrote:dmm wrote:No, YOU are the one missing MY point. I never said what you are accusing me of saying. All the AAAHHHH THUMPY WOOBLE HARRRRRPINK!! in the world can't turn a name like Female or Shithead into an acceptable name. When a parent makes up a name off the top of his/her head, or uses a word he/she didn't understand just because it sounds nice, and it turns out to be a disaster name, then that's funny. And if the name-giver refuses to change the name once the flaw is pointed out, THAT is evidence of gross stupidity, and THAT is the problem.
You still didn't get it. No child has ever been named Shithead, Shi-thead or Shi'thead. White people made this up. "Look, black parents are so stupid!" Please read the explanation in this 2007 Snopes article (not the same one as the Le-a one) http://www.snopes.com/racial/language/names.asp
I read it, before I posted last time. It says nothing about the name Shithead, and does not even attempt to disprove any of my statements. Perhaps YOU might want to use a search engine before making blanket statements. For example: http://community.babycenter.com/post/a2 ... not_joking Also, you might want to study logic, instead of AAAHHHH THUMPY WOOBLE HARRRRRPINK!!.
dmm wrote:babble wrote:Betsy is short for Elizabeth, not Margaret. Did you mean Peg/Peggy/Meg? Those are short for Margaret.
I knew a woman named Margaret, and she went by Betsy. I assumed that was correct. The web says you are right. If I meet her again, should I tell her?
Ronsonic wrote:Beyond the Idiocracy-like product names there are options like Cosmolene and Linolea.
Some years ago there was a study that, according to the headlines, showed widespread racism in hiring. The study used a bunch of recent college graduate resumes off the internet and randomly matched them to racially identifiable names from hospital records from the appropriate time. And yes, overall, the "black" names got fewer calls from employers.
What was interesting was reading the actual results that showed black employers just as discriminating / discriminatory as white. Then when you get to the raw numbers - Ebony did as well as Heather, it was Quan'esha who couldn't get date and was dragging down the average for the side. Same for the guys, nobody was calling D'Andre while Tyrone was hanging with Tyler and Jeremy.
dmm wrote:I read it, before I posted last time. It says nothing about the name Shithead,
and does not even attempt to disprove any of my statements. Perhaps YOU might want to use a search engine before making blanket statements. For example: http://community.babycenter.com/post/a2 ... not_joking
Also, you might want to study logic, instead of AAAHHHH THUMPY WOOBLE HARRRRRPINK!!.
Monika wrote:I also have doubts about girls being named Female. It's not a terrible name and not as unlikely as Shi['|-]thead, but I have never seen proof beyond "I knew someone with this name", which could very well mean "a friend told me s/he knew a woman with this name", which in turn could mean "a friend who read this in a chain mail claimed s/he knew a woman with this name".
So, my wife's a liar, huh?
Nice. You refuse to believe anything that contradicts your personal "reality."
"Fryer and Levitt find that the rise in distinctively black names took place in the early 1970s. While previous studies found having a black name harmful, they conclude that having a distinctively black name is primarily a consequence rather than a cause of poverty and segregation."
My commentary:
So we see that
1) distinctively black (i.e., made-up) names is a fairly recent phenomenon, not something deeply rooted in African-American culture (as you falsely claimed); and
Cactus Wren wrote:I'm embarrassed to admit I know this much about those crap books, but Corbo's right: Renesmee is the result of a violent impact between "Esme" and "Renee".
Wikipedia wrote:Her unusual first name (pronounced like the word "cage") is a combination of the names of her two grandmothers, Kate and Genevieve.
Monika wrote:It's entirely logical and factual that white people discriminate against black people and that white people as the dominant group see their way of naming children as the only right way.
Yablo wrote:I once told my mother that I'd like a son named Formica and a daughter named Travesty. She hit me. She didn't hit my father for trying to name me Treasure and my brother Scavenger even though our last name is Hunt.
Also, a prediction I made a few years ago in a conversation with my brother: With as bad as some people are about saying "lol" or "Gee Willikers" and the like in actual conversation, I wouldn't be surprised if we start seeing names with numbers like Steven2012 or Kelly42 soon.
bavariati wrote:It can happen to anyone, even one of my favorite sci-fi writers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kage_BakerWikipedia wrote:Her unusual first name (pronounced like the word "cage") is a combination of the names of her two grandmothers, Kate and Genevieve.
Monika wrote:Ronsonic wrote:Beyond the Idiocracy-like product names there are options like Cosmolene and Linolea.
Some years ago there was a study that, according to the headlines, showed widespread racism in hiring. The study used a bunch of recent college graduate resumes off the internet and randomly matched them to racially identifiable names from hospital records from the appropriate time. And yes, overall, the "black" names got fewer calls from employers.
I have seen such studies.What was interesting was reading the actual results that showed black employers just as discriminating / discriminatory as white. Then when you get to the raw numbers - Ebony did as well as Heather, it was Quan'esha who couldn't get date and was dragging down the average for the side. Same for the guys, nobody was calling D'Andre while Tyrone was hanging with Tyler and Jeremy.
I have not seen such studies. Please provide links.
Van wrote:Fireballs don't lie.
bavariati wrote:Cactus Wren wrote:I'm embarrassed to admit I know this much about those crap books, but Corbo's right: Renesmee is the result of a violent impact between "Esme" and "Renee".
It can happen to anyone, even one of my favorite sci-fi writers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kage_BakerWikipedia wrote:Her unusual first name (pronounced like the word "cage") is a combination of the names of her two grandmothers, Kate and Genevieve.
(Empress of Mars is a good intro to her style. Fun like Heinlein, but without the machismo.)
CatOfGrey wrote:My wife and I actually combined our last names when we married, but it worked out really well poetically.
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep -i dilbert /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1916.txt:Dilbert,M,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1926.txt:Dilbert,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1928.txt:Dilbert,M,7
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep -i female /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1981.txt:Female,F,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1982.txt:Female,F,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1983.txt:Female,F,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1984.txt:Female,F,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1985.txt:Female,F,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1986.txt:Female,F,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1987.txt:Female,F,32
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1988.txt:Female,F,57
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1989.txt:Female,F,43
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1990.txt:Female,F,156
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1991.txt:Female,F,149
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1992.txt:Female,F,94
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1993.txt:Female,F,90
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1994.txt:Female,F,106
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1995.txt:Female,F,106
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1996.txt:Female,F,42
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1997.txt:Female,F,22
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1998.txt:Female,F,22
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1999.txt:Female,F,23
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2000.txt:Female,F,17
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2001.txt:Female,F,15
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2002.txt:Female,F,20
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2003.txt:Female,F,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2004.txt:Female,F,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2005.txt:Female,F,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2005.txt:Infantfemale,F,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2006.txt:Female,F,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Female,F,28
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1989.txt:Female,M,5
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep Sue,M /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1917.txt:Sue,M,7
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1927.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1928.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1930.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1931.txt:Sue,M,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1932.txt:Sue,M,7
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1933.txt:Sue,M,7
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1934.txt:Sue,M,14
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1935.txt:Sue,M,13
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1936.txt:Sue,M,9
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1937.txt:Sue,M,12
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1938.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1940.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1941.txt:Sue,M,16
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1942.txt:Sue,M,15
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1943.txt:Sue,M,19
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1944.txt:Sue,M,15
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1945.txt:Sue,M,16
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1946.txt:Sue,M,17
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1947.txt:Sue,M,12
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1948.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1949.txt:Sue,M,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1950.txt:Sue,M,9
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1951.txt:Sue,M,14
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1953.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1955.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1957.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1958.txt:Sue,M,15
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1959.txt:Sue,M,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1960.txt:Sue,M,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1961.txt:Sue,M,9
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1963.txt:Sue,M,6
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1964.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1966.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1971.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1974.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1979.txt:Sue,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1981.txt:Sue,M,7
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1982.txt:Sue,M,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1983.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1984.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1985.txt:Sue,M,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1986.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1987.txt:Sue,M,8
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1988.txt:Sue,M,18
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1989.txt:Sue,M,14
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1990.txt:Sue,M,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1991.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1992.txt:Sue,M,7
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1993.txt:Sue,M,10
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1994.txt:Sue,M,9
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob1996.txt:Sue,M,11
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep -i renesmee /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2009.txt:Renesmee,F,18
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Renesmee,F,47
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep ,5 /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Treasure,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Zyquarius,M,5
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Zzyzx,M,5
MongoLT:~ Mongo$ grep Name, /Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/*
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Name,F,11
/Users/Mongo/Downloads/names/yob2010.txt:Name,M,13
netwebber wrote:I also know an American couple who moved to Israel and would rather their children not move back to the U.S., but wanted everyone to retain their American citizenship (for American passports, in case the State of Israel is destroyed, etc.). They all have normal Israeli names, with the last name "Berkowicz" (spelling changed to protect the guilty).
They tried not giving one child a first name when they applied for a passport. The State Department rejected the application, so they named him "Just." Get it? No first name, "Just Berkowicz."
Second child: First name: Berkowicz. Middle name: James. Full name: Berkowicz. James Berkowicz.
drummond93 wrote:Immigrant names as recorded in English by immigration officers (Ellis Island, etc) were often written phonetically/ or as best one could manage to read approximately similar- and that was when the immigrant actually gave their actual name, as opposed to trying to Americanify it on the spot (lots of immigrants have the first name "John"...
PolakoVoador wrote:lesmith11 wrote:Everytime my grandparents had a girl the mother tried to call it Priscilla... Luckily granddad refused and they all had good biblical names instead
What's wrong with Priscila? It's a very normal and quite common brazilian name
dmm wrote:PolakoVoador wrote:lesmith11 wrote:Everytime my grandparents had a girl the mother tried to call it Priscilla... Luckily granddad refused and they all had good biblical names instead
What's wrong with Priscila? It's a very normal and quite common brazilian name
I hope lesmith11 is joking. Priscilla is a Biblical name.
wormywyrm wrote:I was a little disappointed that:
a) No one on this thread yet posted what the significance of the name 'Renesmee' is.
b) That, upon google search, I found that the name Renesmee was a twilight reference/joke.
tomandlu wrote:Many diseases would make okay names (well, if you were in Ancient Rome)...
Chlamydia, Septicaemia, and so on....
Wnderer wrote:Cactus Wren wrote:I'm embarrassed to admit I know this much about those crap books, but Corbo's right: Renesmee is the result of a violent impact between "Esme" and "Renee".
Nooo. It's the result of the violent impact of Rene Descartes and Mr. Smee
Monika wrote:Uzh wrote:Sometimes I'm very glad to live in a country where you have to proove that the name you want to give already exists. And you are forbidden to give a name which can be used to make fun of the child. Plus the gender of the child should surely be recognised from the name.
You're German? The last requirement has been dropped, gender-neutral names are now allowed.
Monika wrote:Uzh wrote:By now it's quite researched, whether younger underclass parents tend to give especially strange sounding names (which they usually can't pronounce...). This is called "Chantalism" or "Kevinism"
Some Germanistik student/Doktorand writing some paper isn't "researched".
Monika wrote:In reality, rare, unusual or strange names start out in the upper class. Within a couple of years they migrate down, to the distaste of the upper class. This is not new. Double names (like Anne-Marie) started out in the German upper class in the 19th century.
Pfhorrest wrote:Also: Germany was until recently regulating what kind of names people could have? Man, and I thought the Nazis lost power there like 70+ years ago....
Pfhorrest wrote:Germany was until recently regulating what kind of names people could have?
Man, and I thought the Nazis lost power there like 70+ years ago....
Pfhorrest wrote:I am curious what everyone here thinks of names like mine ("Forrest").
JudeMorrigan wrote:Pfhorrest wrote:I am curious what everyone here thinks of names like mine ("Forrest").
Forrest would have struck me as a very nice name, up until the point when Forrest Gump was released. Afterwards? Well, I know how sick *I* got with the "you know what I mean, Verne?" jokes I got being named Ernest. I can only imagine have many "clever" jokes you were subjected to.
Pfhorrest wrote:Also: Germany was until recently regulating what kind of names people could have? Man, and I thought the Nazis lost power there like 70+ years ago....
Return to Individual XKCD Comic Threads
Users browsing this forum: cellocgw, Dracomax, Exodies, geekiskhan, gingermrkettle, htom, Hzza, macraw83, NoMouse, SBN, ToomanyUIDs, ViKing and 45 guests