Azrael001 wrote:I investigated FAOT, he is a student. This makes me more inclined to think that mostlynormal was hoping to get us to lynch two town.
If you truly believe FAOT is town, why are you voting me and not Roband? I've said it a million times.
Here, I'll lay out my reasoning, because I want to know exactly what part you disagree with:
Premise: FAOT is town
Fact: There was no nightkill two nights ago
Fact: The doctor was blocked
Conclusion: Either the roleblocked person was scum, or scum withheld their kill
Fact: FAOT was roleblocked
Conclusion: Scum withheld their kill (lines 1 and 5)
Fact: Scum would rather have a kill than no kill
Fact: Scum would rather get a townie lynched than have a kill
Conclusion: If scum withheld their kill, scum thought they could get a townie lynched
Fact: Roband was the only one who knew he was blocking FAOT
Probable: scum very probably would have no reason to withhold the kill without Roband's information (line 9 and info from two nights ago)
Probable conclusion: Roband is scum
I suppose we disagree on how "probable" that second to last line is. But to me it seems nearly impossible that scum knew enough to withhold the kill without Roband's information.
Anyway, the only reason I'm not putting a vote out yet is I'm not sure who's scummier: FAOT or Roband. They're really both so scummy that even if we didn't have the information from two nights ago I'd beleive that one of them was scum.
Ninja'd: It's funny, FAOT also doctored no one. Roband's point about cop reliability makes some sense, except that if Roband is really innocent then T1mm was a roleblocker and so it's also possible we have godfathers.
Since I can already sense the bandwagon rolling, and I don't want to be lynched:Vote: Roband
Because if he flips scum we'll be at 4v1 worst case, and if he flips town we've won because we know FAOT and Az are scum. (In the FAOT lynch, we'll get 3v2 with one scum still unknown if he's town, winning in the best case if he's scum)
Ninja'd again: Ok so I'm not under threat, but the above reasoning still makes me want to vote Roband