Azrael001 wrote:That both of them have investigation results that have come up town?
Unless there is some scum power that can consistently obfuscate the results of an investigation, which would be both extremely powerful, and not really something that I would expect in a "newbies game", then none of the results are trustworthy and we are back to square one.
mpolo wrote:Night 1 is still the big puzzler for me. Unless we have an all-Gryffindor scum team.
Just handwave N1 away? I'm not talking about the fearless not-actually-roleblocked which is very weird, I'm talking about the lack of a nightkill. The roleblock obviously didn't stop the kill, therefore it was withheld or blocked by the doctor. The doctor protected FAOT N1 and that was known amongst hufflepuff. Therefore FAOT is town or he is scum who decided to withhold the kill to earn towny cred D1. However, considering that t1mm didn't know where the RB was going FAOT wouldn't necessarily get any town cred out of the move, and give up a NK is a high price to pay, it virtually guarantees that there will be an extra lynch and extra night of investigations which is terrible for scum. There's no reason they would try something so desperate on N1. Therefore there are no scum in Hufflepuff.roband wrote:Night 1 funny business must have had something to do with Tim.
If you take night 1 and Tim out of this game completely, it becomes very obvious. Therefore, could Tim be to blame for the weirdness on N1? Maybe.
Lataro wrote:Edit: Alternatively to it being dead, all remaining players could truthfully send their role PMs to an outside player and that person takes over as mod to finish it. I'd volunteer, but there would be zero flavor, and I'd pry drop the house scoring to make it easier, so if someone else wanted to, and actually knew the flavor crap involved, that would pry be best.
If scum-FAOT didn't kill Az, they'd either kill me, mpolo, BF, or MN. If they kill BF or MN then that makes it more likely that FAOT is scum (which she is, in this hypothetical scenario), so that's no good. Keep in mind that if we lynch one more scum, slytherins power gets much much better (I'm assuming there's 2 scum left). So scum really want to finish this today. And getting rid of the town-cop has got to feel good.Mostlynormal wrote:If FAOT was scum it wouldn't make sense for scum to NK Az, since my entire plan was to lynch FAOT then Az.
Adam H wrote:Vote: MostlyNormal
mpolo wrote:Mostlynormal went through an extremely scummy period yesterday, and FAOT has been so tied up in the weirdness surrounding roband that I am reasonably certain of his scumminess as well.
Adam H wrote:Seems like BF and mpolo are the calm voices of reason, doesn't it... I am definitely leaning towards a MN+FAOT scumteam.
Adam H wrote:Can everyone tell me why they trust mpolo and me? It's kind of unnerving, honestly.
No, the game would not have been up. We would be operating under the assumption that FAOT and Az are scum, so we'd discount whatever Az said and we'd lynch FAOT no matter what. At least, I would have. A mislynch means a scum win (assuming there's 2 more scum), so we couldn't do a "lynch BF/MN and then if they're town we know Az is scum".ForAllOfThis wrote:From my perspective, it's pretty obvious we are looking at a MN + BF scum team now. I think it's no coincidence as soon as I give up control of the doctor, that Azrael dies the same night... He was going to have to investigate one of them tonight so if they didn't kill him last night, then the game would have been up today.
Adam H wrote:What does everyone think happened N1? No NK, and fearless getting roleblocked yet receiving a (true) cop result. We know that FAOT wasn't attacked because there's at least one scum in hufflepuff, so that's no longer an explanation for the lack of NK.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests