Snark, That's because I really don't think your suspicion that I'm scummy because I'm an SK really holds water. I had a defense, it's this.
tastelikecoke wrote:But wait, talking about one role makes you more likely to be that role? It's really more like WIFOM to follow that reasoning.
To expound that further, Imagine you are an SK, with the exact description as you are incriminating me with. You would probably think of some plan to cover up your identity. You read upon the rules, Hey, it shows here that an SK is impossible, if you consider it a third party
. You thought "I'll mention that and I'll get away and have some tea while I stab people."
This is just as likely as any town misinterpreting the rules. Would an SK really go the trouble? Well, there's a chance for a gambit, or any magnificent bastard thinking it over, but do you really think that would mean I am definitely pinging as an SK?
Also, as for your reason 4.
Snark wrote:4. Voted Angua while still saying he'd by open to lynching one of the many lurkers in game.
Sure, but why does it make me scummy? That's just a description of what I did.
well then, bandwagon's bandwagon for Matt96 and fearless. o_o do you have something against me just because I mentioned you guys weren't posting much?
fearless wrote:TLC claims it is *not* uncommon for SK and mafia to target the same person on N1. Lol? In a game this size, I think the probability of that happening is pretty low.
Mafia and SKs have same things common in their mind. They want to kill people who is helpful for town. It's still possible, not impossible enough to make us sure that one night kill means one faction.
Really, this is a very flimsy argument to vote me though. You even argued that talking about SKs are a bit premature. Didn't we discuss how important an SK is to the setup? This is a bit OMGUS-y butunvote
I would prefer this against an Angua lynch.