Moderators: Moderators General, Magistrates, Prelates
thelastholdout wrote:I don't get this whole attitude that one must be talented in a field in order to be able to criticize a work in that field.
Case in point: I'm a terrible singer, and I can't play worth a damn, but I know an awful band when I hear them. And I am entitled to rage at the injustice when an awful band is pushed as a good band.
thelastholdout wrote:lly wrote:CorruptUser wrote:If you think Randall is doing a terrible job, make your own webcomic and do a better job.
If you think Twilight is terrible, why don't you become a published novelist and show how it should be done?
I don't get this whole attitude that one must be talented in a field in order to be able to criticize a work in that field.
Case in point: I'm a terrible singer, and I can't play worth a damn, but I know an awful band when I hear them. And I am entitled to rage at the injustice when an awful band is pushed as a good band.
CorruptUser wrote:If you think Randall is doing a terrible job, make your own webcomic and do a better job.
thelastholdout wrote:I understand that this is a comic, but "you have terrible taste" seems to be unnecessarily harsh.
LE4dGOLEM wrote:your ability to tell things from things remains one of your skills.
Weeks wrote:Not only can you tell things from things, you can recognize when a thing is a thing
SexyTalon wrote:Djehutynakht wrote:I'm confused. In the last panel, is he putting it back and escaping the critical room, or is someone else on the other side locking him in the room in a BHG-esque attempt at getting rid of everyone who doesn't share his literary tastes?
This should be a fun bookstore. I wonder what happens if someone picks up Twilight...
Neither. The click is the bookshelf returning to it's original position. Our Hero hasn't moved, likely in stunned surprise/shock/WTF-ery.

Flynn777 wrote:blowfishhootie wrote:Flynn777 wrote:Randall, I defy you to name another philosopher that you agree with 90% of the time. If you reply "Aristotle" then you haven't read enough of his material.
"You have terrible taste" is a disappointingly lazy reply.
"Agreeing with 90 percent of every sentence" is not the same thing as "agreeing 90 percent of the time." More than 10 percent of Ayn Rand's message is summed up with "be a huge asshole to everyone."
It's not? Then what, pray tell, is it the same thing as? I suppose one could say that every sentence consisted of 9 variants of "2+2=4" and then concluded with "Jesus died for your sins." But, having bothered to read Atlas Shrugged, I can say with certainty that this is not the case.
Rand did a profoundly better job expressing her philosophy in fiction, where her characters aren't particularly assholes in any way that the average XKCD reader isn't totally condescending to everyone else in his or her life, than in her non-fiction, where she was attempting to rationalize the difference between her vision and her personal behavior.
"Agreeing with 90 percent of every sentence" is not the same thing as "agreeing 90 percent of the time." More than 10 percent of Ayn Rand's message is summed up with "be a huge asshole to everyone."
Rand's concept of self-interest doesn't allow for that, because it encourages ignoring externalities and side effects.
MockFerret wrote:I always find this kind of debate about Rand kind of interesting, largely because precisely nobody outside of the USA gives a monkey's about her, and very few have even heard of her.
I tried reading Atlas Shrugged, but didn't get very far. I'd say that if people over here have an opinion of her at all, it's as "That nutter the Americans use as an excuse to be shitty to each other."BrianX wrote:I'd actually love to know what people outside the US think of Ayn Rand. I would imagine she comes off as quite strange and a little psycho to most people.
MockFerret wrote:I tried reading Atlas Shrugged, but didn't get very far. I'd say that if people over here have an opinion of her at all, it's as "That nutter the Americans use as an excuse to be shitty to each other."BrianX wrote:I'd actually love to know what people outside the US think of Ayn Rand. I would imagine she comes off as quite strange and a little psycho to most people.
I tried reading Atlas Shrugged, but didn't get very far. I'd say that if people over here have an opinion of her at all, it's as "That nutter the Americans use as an excuse to be shitty to each other."
BrianX wrote:I'd actually love to know what people outside the US think of Ayn Rand. I would imagine she comes off as quite strange and a little psycho to most people.
thelastholdout wrote:I understand that this is a comic, but "you have terrible taste" seems to be unnecessarily harsh.
One day, I may find someone, somewhere, who disagrees with what Ayn Rand says while accurately quoting what she says.
TazTheTerrible wrote:On the actual topic of Ayn Rand though: is there any good reason to actually read Atlas shrugged or any of her books?
I could, but then I could just rejoin my fellow countrymen and go back to not caring one way or the other.HugoSchmidt wrote:I tried reading Atlas Shrugged, but didn't get very far. I'd say that if people over here have an opinion of her at all, it's as "That nutter the Americans use as an excuse to be shitty to each other."
Well, yes, I'm sure that that's the correct interpretation.
On the other hand, she's the person who opposed the Vietnam War without making excuses for the Vietcong and Khmer Rouge, had Henry Kissinger's number at a time when it would have made a difference, understood that America's foreign policy was both immoral and impractical when it was unfashionable to do so, attacked the grotesque indulgence of certain conservatives for racism long before that was fashionable...
..and so on.
But, hey. Keep telling yourself that mantra. You might even believe it.
Soultaker~ wrote:TazTheTerrible wrote:On the actual topic of Ayn Rand though: is there any good reason to actually read Atlas shrugged or any of her books?
Obviously nobody can answer this for you. You'll just have to take a chance. Personally I thought it was interesting even though I didn't agree with Rand everywhere. And I'd say that even if the prose isn't the best, it's still much better written than the Bible.
I suggest you start by reading Anthem (freely available), which is pretty short, and then decide if you feel up to the task of reading 700 (for The Fountainhead) or 1,000 (for Atlas Shrugged) or so more pages with the same underpinning philosophy.
Trimix wrote:Dude!
Ayn Rand rocks! Unless you are a communist.
LE4dGOLEM wrote:your ability to tell things from things remains one of your skills.
Weeks wrote:Not only can you tell things from things, you can recognize when a thing is a thing
nccn wrote:One day, I may find someone, somewhere, who disagrees with what Ayn Rand says while accurately quoting what she says.
Her ideas don't really jive with history, or reality, or logic.
1) A Laissez-faire economy has never existed and will never exist, nor does any thinking person really believe that unrestrained trade would be the ideal method for human existence. I have yet to meet anyone who feels that organ donations should go to the highest bidder, that every drug should be legalized and uncontrolled, that Richard really owes his kingdom for a horse, and that murder for hire should be legal. Once you admit that the freedom to contract is not absolute your argument becomes a mere one of degree rather than kind.
jpk wrote:I had a hard time with Ayn Rand because I found myself enthusiastically agreeing with the first 90% of every sentence, but getting lost at "therefore, be a huge asshole to everyone.
Return to Individual XKCD Comic Threads
Users browsing this forum: apprentice_fu, arjan, BlueCrab, Caswallon, Ebonite, edo, Exodies, HAL9000, jetpac, MobTeeseboose, moody7277, mscha, Opiboble, pelrigg, Red Hal, Tova, ttscp, WriteBrainedJR, yappobiscuits and 33 guests