Moderators: jestingrabbit, Moderators General, Prelates
ForAllOfThis wrote:If we hit what I think will be the last mafia with one of them, then look at lynching t1mm or boomfrog the day after
Silas wrote:Nobody who gets paid by the hour invents a cotton gin.
fearless wrote:I'm ok with a JSO lynch but not cpt'finglass
fearless wrote:I'm ok with a JSO lynch but not cpt'finglass
ForAllOfThis wrote:I think finglass is more likely scum-buddies with Adam than JSO is. A gut feeling more than anything else.
ForAllOfThis wrote:Well, as you can probably tell now, I copped Webby night 1. Notice how I was suspicous of him D1, and then didn't bring it up again?
I targetted JSO last night but didn't get a result. I'm assuming I was roleblocked. Scum too scared to risk killing me, so just took away my power instead. Honestly, I couldn't decide between finglass or JSO and ended up flipping a coin on who to cop, so really need to hear more from the both of them.
ForAllOfThis wrote:Well, as you can probably tell now, I copped Webby night 1. Notice how I was suspicous of him D1, and then didn't bring it up again?
I targetted JSO last night but didn't get a result. I'm assuming I was roleblocked. Scum too scared to risk killing me, so just took away my power instead. Honestly, I couldn't decide between finglass or JSO and ended up flipping a coin on who to cop, so really need to hear more from the both of them.
JSO wrote:Or you just didn't check your role PM until after D1 ended so you could play without bias (as many people do, to my knowledge). Then you found out webby was your scumbuddy. You weren't killed last night, so that makes me assume that you're scum.
JesseScottOwen wrote:Or you just didn't check your role PM until after D1 ended so you could play without bias (as many people do, to my knowledge). Then you found out webby was your scumbuddy. You weren't killed last night, so that makes me assume that you're scum.
Misnomer wrote:Webby has been killed in the night. He was the Doctor, Town, and could protect one player from night kills each night.
FAOT wrote:[Scum] were scared [to nightkill me] because I had copped a doctor D1 so I knew I could be protected.
ForAllOfThis wrote:fearless wrote:I'm ok with a JSO lynch but not cpt'finglass
Why?
wam wrote:I am also a cop/seer, I get told whether a person is evil or not evil.
Table 1: the dead
Scum Town Other
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Snark (mafia doctor) Lataro (anarchist) DMC (druid)
Adam (mafia rolecop) webby (doctor)
Angua (wolf graverobber) timn01994 (priest)
Outuendo (wolf tracker) TLC (minister)
Krong (wolf redirect) mostlynormal(innkeeper)
Table 2: the living
Player Role info Role info
(mafia cop / wolf cop) (sane cop / insane cop)
---------------------------------------------------------------
wam claimed seer ---
Finglass not mafia scum
(fearless cop result) (fearless insane cop result)
FAOT claimed limited rolecop ---
fearless claimed cop ---
JSO not werewolf town
(wam seer result) (fearless insane cop result)
mafia (wam sane cop result)
(fearless cop result)
greenlover n/a ---
BoomFrog n/a ---
Matt96 n/a ---
ahammel n/a ---
Table 1: the dead
Scum Town Other
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Snark (mafia doctor) Lataro (anarchist) DMC (druid)
Adam (mafia rolecop) webby (doctor)
Angua (wolf graverobber) timn01994 (priest)
Outuendo (wolf tracker) TLC (minister)
Krong (wolf redirect) mostlynormal(innkeeper)
Table 2: the living
Player Role info Role info
(mafia cop / wolf cop) (sane cop / insane cop)
---------------------------------------------------------------
wam claimed seer ---
Finglass not mafia scum
(fearless cop result) (fearless insane cop result)
FAOT claimed limited rolecop ---
fearless claimed cop town
not werewolf (wam sane cop result)
(wam seer result) ---
JSO not werewolf town
(wam seer result) (fearless insane cop result)
mafia (wam sane cop result)
(fearless cop result)
greenlover n/a ---
BoomFrog n/a ---
Matt96 n/a ---
ahammel n/a ---
fearless wrote:coz I investigated finglass on N2 and he [sic. Capt. Finglass prefers 'she'] came clean. JSO last night and was criminal. Timm the first night and didn't get a result.
ahammel wrote:FAOT wrote:[Scum] were scared [to nightkill me] because I had copped a doctor D1 so I knew I could be protected.
So you're saying that scum rolecopped webby as well and killed him instead of playing WIFOM with an NK on you? I suppose that's plausible.
greenlover wrote:wam - if you really think that finglass is a werewolf, you should prefer lynching her over JSO. This is simply because that would remove one nk from the game, while we still need to find the other mafia member to remove the mafia nk.
ForAllOfThis wrote:greenlover wrote:wam - if you really think that finglass is a werewolf, you should prefer lynching her over JSO. This is simply because that would remove one nk from the game, while we still need to find the other mafia member to remove the mafia nk.
This reads to me as greenlover trying to keep JSO alive, and an extra NK in the game (if JSO is the last mafia). This could only benefit an indepedent or SK.
greenlover wrote:Also something we should note about matt's claim - nothing he claimed is new information that can be verified. Both Lataro and tim are dead, and fearless already claimed that she targeted Finglass N2. Given that he suddenly claimed out of the blue right when it was growing pretty darn clear that JSO is today's lynch target and used his claim to place a vote on BF, it gives me the impression of our 4th mafia trying to save his buddy's hide.
greenlover wrote:Fearless, did you just claim cop? Just want to make sure we're all on the same page here.
If fearless really did just claim cop, then I'm up for a JSO lynch, certainly. If he flips town, then we can go after fearless, who must thus necessarily be scum. If he flips a towny miller, then... he was kinda lame for not claiming that at the beginning of the game.
Silas wrote:Nobody who gets paid by the hour invents a cotton gin.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests