mpolo wrote:There's not a lot of time to hash this out, but I'm a little worried about how fast the Sabrar wagon is going. On the other hand, the arguments are reasonably solid -> Sabrar seems to have discounted cult as an option. Even in his defense about what he believed about cults, if he really believed that that could be the case, he would be in a complete panic as a townie.
Votals at the time of your post:
Sabrar (3) : somitomi, BoomFrog, Peaceful Whale
bessie (1) : LaserGuy
Not voting: heuristically_alone, Gopher of Pern, Sabrar, bessie, mpolo
Why were you worried? Did you really think that there would be a hammer with two days remaining? By who? If you are worried about Sabrar being lynched, you could try looking for scum somewhere besides Sabrar, instead of discussing the setup. The only player you have commented on in this entire game is Sabrar.
Gopher of Pern wrote:I'm pretty sure bessie was making the point that Cult would recruit those who always appear to be townie (i.e. bessie), so they don't get lynched.
Oh, okay, I understand what she's getting at now. Is a townie in a cult game the same as a townie in a mafia game? I feel like there ought to be some differences in terms of how you evaluate town/scum in a cult game that might not always bring you to the same conclusions, but I don't exactly know how to articulate what I think differences might be.
You voted for me and joked that it was the only vote I would receive all game. If you have a chance to skim Dracualfia, you’ll see that moody was pushing my lynch because he thought I was the most likely cult recruit (does someone want to let somitomi and Peaceful Whale in on the joke?). I asked you earlier what cult might look for in a recruit, and you answered key power roles. Well, great, so cult recruits Cyclops, it’s not going to do them any good if Cyclops is the scummiest player in the game and gets lynched or investigated.
D2 when we might have a better idea of the setup we can discuss strategies for determining cult. D1 it will be similar to hunting mafia, because they haven’t recruited yet. I think the most important thing we can do is keep everyone talking. Lots and lots. I am going to be especially suspicious of anyone lurking on D1, because then we won’t have enough content to compare it to D2.
BoomFrog wrote: somitomi wrote:
Peaceful Whale wrote:Just tell me who to vote
Can't we just wait until more of the day has elapsed? I don't see any reason to rush, the extension
we received gives us ample time to think.
Thinking won't get us anywhere without discussion. Discussion is empty without strong opinions.
Agree. If anyone is having trouble thinking of something to say, they can always make an ordered town-scum list. I really like ordered lists.
Gopher of Pern wrote:
But still, if there is a cult, storm will be culted. Or bessie. (possibly both!