Aargh, these last few reads are slow going, and now I’m starting to get ninja’d by the players I’m reading. Evil George Washington
– I had some initial concern that he was going to be difficult about the wall of text thing, and I’m not overly happy about the rapid fire multiple posts. But other than that, I like his style. I like the authoritative pushing other players for content, and holding them to answer questions. He was a little guarded in his early opinions, but not in an anti-town way, as he did not hold back from answering direct questions, he just waited to be asked (he reminds me of someone else that I like to play with a lot
My comments on his reads lists here
, because he asked.
Evil George Washington wrote:Peaceful Whale - I think Peace Whale is putting his foot in his mouth far too many times to be a strong candidate for mafia.
I don’t agree with this, I think that he’s putting his foot in his mouth because he’s trying too hard to act townie, but I am also considering that maybe he is trying too hard because he is town. I can see this game being quite intimidating for newbie town, not just newbie scum.
I don’t agree with the read on plytho. I have the same thoughts as you about Znirk. I’m kinda surprised you don’t have anything
on FrozenFlame, not even a prod. Agree with the scum lean on jimbob but for slightly different reasons. I think that the concerns about moody are valid. I’m still thinking about BoomFrog. jimbobmacdoodle
– Current scum lean. Read my latest comments on him here
. I’m going to put off commenting further until he posts some more content, which I’m sure will be soon and plentiful, because jimbob doesn’t generally lurk as scum (or at all, and he did say he would be unavailable this weekend).
I may need to save my two most difficult analysis/reads (three really, I need a real analysis of BoomFrog) for tomorrow because I’m running out of steam. Let me see if I can come up with anything before I fall asleep.