moody7277 wrote: Had I gotten anything like a yes or no I would have taken it into consideration. All I got was "you really shouldn't have claimed that now" and wam's "claim everything now, you promised".
Ok, it’s been discussed enough that I’ll chime in. I didn’t want to push discussing your power too much because if you give out details of how your power works, then it will become useless. My opinion is that you shouldn’t have claimed, and I find it suspicious that you did claim. I am not a fan of players claiming on D1, and I’ve said this before. For an example, see this post
I think that if you want to use your power, ok, you’re not a newbie, you’re experienced enough to decide whether or not it’s the right call. But why claim it first? You could have claimed on D2, and then we could have worked out any night results. And if you die, we still might be able to work it out.
LaserGuy wrote:6. Flips will reveal all role details including hidden mechanics
And as to my opinion as to whether or not you should use it, I too abstain from offering an opinion. If you are scum, you will use it or not, and you will tell us truth or you will lie and we won’t know which. If you are town, you have already given information to scum and there is no need to give them more.
Liri wrote:If I was needed to cast a tie-breaking vote, I probably would.
Liri, it’s important for townies to vote, or scum can control the lynch. This comment implies that you don’t really have an opinion on who is scum and who is town, or you don’t care. Like you won't commit to a read, but you do care about making sure that you’re available to decide the lynch.
Sabrar wrote:And now we see why plytho wanted so hard to establish his stubbornness as non-alignment-indicative.
So are you implying that plytho is purposely trying to develop this as his meta? Because he already claimed otherwise here
. Or are you saying that plytho is just naturally stubborn, like...like maybe...you?
Suzaku wrote:We need at least 2 more votes on wam because Suzaku will vote Madge.
At least if he voted he would be contributing something to the game.
Sabrar wrote:I've concluded that somitomi is the indie. Of course he'll never admit it, not after X-Men.
Well of course I wouldn't, not when you are in the game...
Would you admit it if Sabrar were not in the game?
Sabrar wrote:I'll allow jimbob to enter Core Town though he needs to unvote at some point.
Sabrar, are you more interested in lynching scum or not lynching Madge?
Liri wrote:Read Wam's posts in isolation and nothing strikes me as being worthy of a great deal of suspicion. Moves much closer to town in my estimation.
Being asked for content, my first instinct towards the asker has been, "okay, they're definitely town," but I'm realizing that playing the elder states(wo)man towards the noob is an easy way to win them (me) over. Not that I'm now thinking they're scummy, just more cautious.
Liri, do you have a solid opinion on anyone? Please make a town-scum list, with no groupings.
plytho wrote:Although there’s usually more reasoning accompanying her reads lists.
Noted. I will try to compile all my reads in to a list. I think everything is out there, just spread out among my posts.
Sabrar wrote:@jimbob: Madge is not the criminal mastermind bessie believes her to be.
Sabrar, I think (yet again) you underestimate Madge. I know you did the big meta read of her for Crossover, but you were scum, and you had reason for wanting to keep her in the game, as she was busy, overwhelmed, and not following the game closely (and for the gameplay reasons that she was jailed, could lose her vote, and would probably never gain a power). Her content this game has been winey, she doesn't intend to vote, why are you so determined she's town?Vote: Madge