Why do you feel the need to dictate my reads to me? I just spent four hours Sunday night trying to read you, if you’re town I will do my best and try to figure it out from your content, not from you telling me “would I do this as scum?” which always sounds suspicious when anyone does that. And if Madge had flipped scum, there was a possibility that you would have had me all to yourself, as I possibly would have tunneled you. But since we’re still looking for two scum, you’re going to have to share me with the others.BoomFrog wrote:It seems to me that although I protected Madge D1 I attacked her D2, so if she had flipped scum you shouldn't have thought I was scummy in that situation. I would be a pretty awful player if I got my two scum-buddies lynched D1 and D2, especially in a newbie game. So why would I "have you all to myself"?
BoomFrog, if there is a specific post that you want me to comment on can you link it please?
I see how you find me me me interesting, and I’d like to believe you find all my posts interesting. But I don’t see how you find that post suspicious. I start by considering all possibilities and narrow my view from the large picture to the specific, not the other way around.Sabrar wrote:Except to possible scum!you. Do you really not see why I find that interesting?bessie wrote:Now they’re all incorrect because moody wasn’t scum, and PW wasn’t town. But neither of those things were known on D1
Ok, sigh, what did you expect? How would you like me to organize my results, and what format should I follow? I just did a search at everyspec dot com for a copy of GAME-STD-9001: Mafia – Model for Quality Assurance in Design, Development, Production, and Playing but was unable to find a copy of the standard; I also checked ISO dot org and came up empty. So please forward me a copy, along with the following Standard Operating Procedures:Sabrar wrote:@bessie: ok, now I understand what you did, it's just that the result (or how you presented it) was not what I expected.
OP 01 Mafia Design & Project Management
OP 02 Modding & Planning
OP 03 Player Process Procedures
OP 04 Control of Nonconforming Posts
OP 05 Corrective Action
Well then you haven’t read my posts. I don’t do fluff. Ok, there was some fluff, like the fluff about the late BessieDog. But the remainder of my content is solid, and you really should read every word. I can break my posts up and I probably should so that I’m easier to quote, but I also feel that the form is important to understanding my thought process, and that something might be lost in translation.flicky1991 wrote: I dislike long posts that don't seem to actually be saying much,
This is a sensible speculation in regards to my “coaching” interactions with Peaceful Whale, so I’ll help you out and give you not only my point of view but an example from a past game. Scum!me absolutely would not put all my advice in chat and would put some advice in thread. MasonMe gave Peaceful Whale advice in thread and in chat when I was mason partners with him in Crossover (read the chat log). Ok, next. I want to say that I have *just about* had it with being accused of being scum for trying to help out a newbie. I try to help out newbies whenever I can, read WoT1, Matrix 6 Newbie, WoT2 (though you have to dig through Gojoe for this one), Bin Chicken (mentor), Crossover, Shakespeare III, etc. My willingness to help out newbies is non alignment indicative. I’ve tried to help out newbie town when I was scum (see WoT1). And I’ve had trying to help out a newbie scum, in Shakespeare, when I was town, destroy that game for me, and it was the game that I was looking forward to more than any other game I’ve played on this forum.flicky1991 wrote: and your interactions towards Whale D1 could be you trying not to put all your help for him in scum chat.
I think you are quite enjoying your atypical confirmed town status.Sabrar wrote:Silly meta-read incoming.
And that’s fine. I don’t mind being read as a cold heartless bitch that would bus a partner for game purposes, I would take it as a compliment to my skill. I do mind being read as someone that is scummy just for giving advice to a newbie that needed some, and I will not take it as a compliment if you read me as a cold heartless bitch that is only kind for her own direct benefit.jimbobmacdoodle wrote:I need to go back over bessie's D1 content to convince myself whether she could have attacked her buddy as much as she did.
I will almost certainly re-woof this list later, I’m still thinking, but that's my two hours for the night.