Madge wrote:@Madge: why are you voting Sabrar? In particular, if you think bessie and Sabrar are buddies, why are you voting him and not bessie?
I don't have any voting related power or restriction, though. [/quote]You never actually answered my question. Let me put it another way: why are you voting bessie and not Sabrar?
How are your votes being helpful?Madge wrote:Trying to focus on being helpful. and having some chaotic fun, but hopefully not too much.
This seems like quite an extreme reaction. I've suggested several theories, some of which are likely wrong. Are you going to vote me? How about Madge, who just enumerated different reasons why alignments weren't revealed, one or more of which are likely wrong?ConMan wrote:Vote Sabrar
FoS everyone else who jumped on that bandwagon
Not true: you pointed out that mpolo's name was not revealed, unlike Vicarin. I suppose the evidence was there before, I just missed it.Sabrar wrote:and no new evidence was brought forward for you to change your mind.
Thank you plytho for your response. No further follow up there until I've reviewed D1.
Why couldn't the player redirected to Mark have been Mark's killer?ConMan wrote:The N1 deaths were on neither list (so only BoomFrog got redirected to Mark, and only one player got redirected to mpolo), so (again assuming that this set of redirects is final) I know who was actually targeted with the NKs.
Fair comment on the underlined statement. However, what I should have written was that scum are more likely to push those who are not on their team than their buddies, given that this game is likely multiball. Presumably, scum knew he wasn't their buddy.bessie wrote:The underlined implies scum knows they are pushing town.
Why would scum know if Vicarin was town?
Why would Vicarin’s alignment make my push on him suspect?
Your push led to a mislynch. Anything that leads to a mislynch is suspect in my books. Yes, you could be mistaken town, but causing a mislynch increases the chances you are scum.
Go back and see if you can figure out why I asked that question. If you're still not sure and want an answer, then let me know.Sabrar wrote:@jimbob: why is bessie a better vote-target than me if we're buddies?