mpolo wrote:Unfortunately, there hasn't been a lot of movement in thread.
Cool, then you should have time to do detailed analysis and a reads list.
Madge wrote:@bessie i'd be very interested why you're encouraging people to post more in such a direct way, i can only assume you DIDN'T submit a role that interacts with post contents in some way (don't claim either way because it's against the rules to do so obv), because that fishing would not be allowed if you had. but maybe you suspect someone else did. it's the sort of thing i can see someone doing.
Everyone should be posting without needing to be prodded by me. Like you are; you have an extraordinary amount of content so far this game, by D1 Madge standards. You can assume what you want as to whether or not I am fishing or breaking Rule #7 by speculating. But the Sample Town role PM in the OP contains a posting restriction, so if I think about the example while I consider my setup spec, it is possible for other roles to have posting restrictions as well. And I think it’s fair to speculate based on public mod-provided information. If the mods disagree they can slap a penalty on me.
Madge wrote:mpolo's point about sabrar's complaint about the rule is interesting, but you know how Sabrar is with his Opinions about rules, I think he'd still be upset if he was scum. but again a townie place when he could jump on the sabrar wagon if he was scum.
So Madge, what exactly do you think is Sabrar’s complaint, and mpolo's point, and why is it interesting?
Sabrar wrote:And as I have explicitly linked to, scum!moody went out of his way to not make the same joke.
Both ways it’s still the same joke.
Sabrar, I really liked the previous format more, though it seems like I was the only one. I think it gave me better insight into how you read the game. By the way, I failed at the homework assignment. Is it compare Texas and Chaos to each other? Because I’m not seeing anything yet.
Mark_Cangila wrote:I disagree here. I think SJ could easily be scum if there is daychat. From what I've picked up on, many players on here are very reluctant to advise mafia partners, especially newbies.
Depends on the players. You in particular do not like to be coached, you like to appear natural, so you do not receive a lot of coaching from your partners. Compare to Peaceful Whale and Hari Seldon in Newbie New Year. Or if you want to go back four years, you can read Smalltown PyP, where newbie bessie was being heavily coached by the brilliant scum team of Madge, SDK, and Lawrencelot.
SuicideJunkie wrote:- "Many" threads is an exaggeration. I've read a few (3-5?) recent ones for entertainment, not for studying and taking notes.
Interesting, you said in this post
you read DS9, which was so long ago it was before I was even playing regularly.
mpolo wrote:SuicideJunkie has jumped in with both feet, which is to be commended. His content shows that he has done a lot of reading/preparation before starting, so, while I'm inclined to give the newbie some slack, he seems less new than he otherwise might.
Well he implies in the previous post I quoted that he didn’t, that he only casually read a few recent games. And the DS9 Secret Santra from 2013.
MasterOfAll wrote:bessie - seems like normal bessie to me, but being bessie, I'm just neutral on her for now
Interesting, no one ever says that about me. [/sarcasm]
MasterOfAll wrote:Madge - I'm not going to go find it now, but there was 1 specific post she made that gave me strong town vibes
I would be interested in knowing which post you found townie. There are only eight so you should have time to find it before deadline. [/actual request]
BoomFrog wrote: Gambit's are works of art, and you can't force art.
+1, QFT, <3. You don’t need to have a gambit every game, just the ones Vicarin is playing.
MasterOfAll wrote:Basically, I'm saying that something in moody's playstyle usually pings me as scummy
Hahaha another thing no one ever says. [/sarcasm]
Hey, is that another Madge post?? That’s like 11 on D1, and some of them actually have a lot of words in them! I wonder again why the atypical D1 enthusiasm? Not that I don’t like it, I’ve been prodding you for more D1 (D2, D3, etc) content for years.
Madge wrote:forgot about:
one more person i'm sorry for forgetting you but POST MORE
Hahahahahaha, Madge prodding plytho for more content . . . Oh me yarm. . .
Post count, including confirmation posts: